Thermochemical Heterolytic Hydrogenation Catalysis Proceeds Through Polarization-Driven Hydride Transfer

Yogesh Surendranath,Hai-Xu Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-3rp1x
2024-10-16
Abstract:Heterolytic hydrogenations, which split H2 across a hydride acceptor and proton acceptor, are a key class of reactions that span the chemical value chain, including CO2 hydrogenation to formate and NADH regeneration from NAD+. The dominant mechanistic models for heterogeneous catalysis of these reactions invoke classical surface mechanisms that ignore the role of interfacial charge separation. Herein, we quantify the electrochemical potential of the catalyst during turnover and uncover evidence supporting an interfacial electrochemical hydride transfer mechanism for this overall thermochemical reaction class. We find that the proton acceptor induces spontaneous electrochemical polarization of the metal catalyst surface, thereby controlling the thermodynamic hydricity of the surface M–H intermediates and driving rate-determining electrochemical hydride transfer to the hydride acceptor substrate. Overall, this model invokes that heterolytic hydrogenations proceed via the coupling of two electrochemical half-reactions, the hydrogen reduction reaction (HRR) and hydrogen oxidation reaction (HOR), which convert H2 to hydride and proton, respectively. This mechanistic framework, which applies across diverse reaction media and for the hydrogenation of CO2 to formate and NAD+ to NADH, enables the determination of intrinsic reaction kinetics and exposes design principles for the future development of sustainable hydrogenation reactivity.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in heterogeneous catalysis, for heterolytic hydrogenations, the existing classical thermochemical mechanisms cannot explain the relationship between the reaction rate and the alkalinity of the medium. Specifically, the authors focus on how to explain and predict the changes in the hydrogenation reaction rate on the surface of metal catalysts under different alkalinity conditions through the interfacial electrochemical mechanism. These reactions include important chemical conversion processes such as the hydrogenation of carbon dioxide to formate and the regeneration of NAD+ to NADH. ### Core problems of the paper 1. **Understanding the reaction mechanism**: Traditional heterogeneous hydrogenation catalysis models are mainly based on the classical surface mechanism, ignoring the role of interfacial charge separation. This has led to a lack of reasonable explanation for the kinetic behavior of heterolytic hydrogenations under different alkalinity conditions. 2. **Explaining the influence of alkalinity**: It has been experimentally observed that the reaction rate strongly depends on the alkalinity of the medium, but this phenomenon is difficult to explain with the classical hydrogenation mechanism. For example, in the process of CO₂ hydrogenation to formate, alkalinity not only affects the thermodynamics of the reaction but also significantly affects its kinetics. 3. **Proposing a new mechanism**: The authors propose a hydrogenation transfer mechanism based on interfacial electrochemistry, in which alkaline substances induce spontaneous polarization on the surface of metal catalysts, thereby controlling the thermodynamic properties of the surface M - H intermediates and driving the key electrochemical hydrogenation transfer step. ### Specific research contents - **Experimental design**: Use BIM⁺ as a model acceptor and Pt/C as a catalyst to study the heterolytic hydrogenation reaction of H₂ under different alkalinity conditions. The influence of alkalinity on the reaction rate was verified by NMR analysis and potentiometric sensing experiments. - **Theoretical model**: A quantitative relationship between the thermodynamic properties of surface hydrides (ΔG_H⁻,PtH) and the alkalinity of the solution (pKa) was established. Through the Nernst equation and the known surface M - H bond dissociation free energy (BDFE), the main equation was derived: \[ \Delta G_{H^{-},MH} = BDFE_{MH} + F(E_{SHE} - E(H^{\cdot}/H^{-})) - 2.3RT \log[\text{pH}] \] - **Application verification**: This mechanism was applied to the reactions of NAD⁺ hydrogenation to NADH and CO₂ hydrogenation to formate. Through Tafel plots and H/D isotope - labeling experiments, the effectiveness of the electrochemical mechanism was further verified. ### Conclusion The paper proposes a new electrochemical mechanism that explains the kinetic behavior of heterolytic hydrogenations under different alkalinity conditions. This mechanism is applicable not only to organic and inorganic substrates but also effective in non - aqueous and aqueous media. This research provides a new theoretical basis for the design and optimization of sustainable hydrogenation reactions.