Abstract:Code review is an integral part of any mature software development process, and identifying the best reviewer for a code change is a well-accepted problem within the software engineering community. Selecting a reviewer who lacks expertise and understanding can slow development or result in more defects. To date, most reviewer recommendation systems rely primarily on historical file change and review information; those who changed or reviewed a file in the past are the best positioned to review in the future. We posit that while these approaches are able to identify and suggest qualified reviewers, they may be blind to reviewers who have the needed expertise and have simply never interacted with the changed files before. Fortunately, at Microsoft, we have a wealth of work artifacts across many repositories that can yield valuable information about our developers. To address the aforementioned problem, we present CORAL, a novel approach to reviewer recommendation that leverages a socio-technical graph built from the rich set of entities (developers, repositories, files, pull requests (PRs), work items, etc.) and their relationships in modern source code management systems. We employ a graph convolutional neural network on this graph and train it on two and a half years of history on 332 repositories within Microsoft. We show that CORAL is able to model the manual history of reviewer selection remarkably well. Further, based on an extensive user study, we demonstrate that this approach identifies relevant and qualified reviewers who traditional reviewer recommenders miss, and that these developers desire to be included in the review process. Finally, we find that "classical" reviewer recommendation systems perform better on smaller (in terms of developers) software projects while CORAL excels on larger projects, suggesting that there is "no one model to rule them all."

Graph-Based Salient Class Classification in Commits

Salient-class location: help developers understand code change in code review.

Code Review Knowledge Perception: Fusing Multi-Features for Salient-Class Location

Auxiliary Method for Code Commit Comprehension Based on Core-Class Identification

Classifying Code Commits with Convolutional Neural Networks.

Characterizing and Identifying Reverted Commits

Enhancing Bug-Inducing Commit Identification: A Fine-Grained Semantic Analysis Approach

COLARE: Commit Classification Via Fine-grained Context-aware Representation of Code Changes

Program Classification Using Gated Graph Attention Neural Network for Online Programming Service

On Size-Oriented Long-Tailed Graph Classification of Graph Neural Networks

Leveraging structural properties of source code graphs for just-in-time bug prediction

Automatic Classification of Review Comments in Pull-based Development Model.

Semi-Supervised Graph Classification: A Hierarchical Graph Perspective

Using Large-scale Heterogeneous Graph Representation Learning for Code Review Recommendations at Microsoft

Identification of Key Classes in Software Systems Based on Static Analysis and Voting Mechanism

Semi-Supervised Hierarchical Graph Classification

Salient Detection Based on Improved Graph Models

Code classification with graph neural networks: Have you ever struggled to make it work?

Code Revert Prediction with Graph Neural Networks: A Case Study at J.P. Morgan Chase

SmartCommit: a Graph-Based Interactive Assistant for Activity-Oriented Commits

Saliency-aware regularized graph neural network