Abstract:Conformer ranking is a crucial task for drug discovery, with methods for generating conformers often based on molecular (meta)dynamics. These methods are constrained by the underlying force computation regarding runtime and energy ranking accuracy, limiting their effectiveness for large-scale screening applications. To address these ranking limitations, we introduce ConfRank, a machine learning-based approach that enhances conformer ranking using pairwise training. We demonstrate its performance using GFN-FF-generated conformer ensembles, leveraging the DimeNet++ architecture trained on pairs of 159 760 uncharged organic compounds from the GEOM dataset with r2SCAN-3c reference level. Instead of predicting only on single molecules, this approach captures relative energy differences between conformers, leading to a significant improvement of the overall conformational ranking, outperforming GFN-FF and GFN2-xTB. Thereby, the pairwise RMSD of the relative energy difference of two conformers can be reduced from 5.65 kcal mol−1 to 0.71 kcal mol−1 on the test dataset, allowing to correctly identify up to 81 % of all lowest lying conformers correctly (GFN-FF: 10 %, GFN2- xTB: 47 %). The ConfRank approach is cost-effective, allowing for scalable deployment on both CPU and GPU, achieving runtime accelerations by up to two orders of magnitude compared to GFN2-xTB. Out-of-sample investigations on CREST-generated conformer ensembles from the QM9 dataset and conformers taken from an extended GMTKN55 dataset show promising results for the robustness of this approach. Thereby, ranking correlation coefficient such as Spearman can be improved to 0.90 (GFN-FF: 0.39, GFN2-xTB: 0.84) reducing the probability of an incorrect sign flip in pairwise energy comparison from 32 % to 7 %. On the extended GMTKN55 subsets the pairwise MAD (RMSD) could be reduced on almost all subsets by up to 62 % (58 %) with an average improvement of 30 % (29 %). Furthermore, we motivate the usage of the pairwise training approach from a theoretical perspective, highlighting that while pairwise training can lead to a decline in single sample prediction of absolute energies for ML models, it significantly enhances conformer ranking performance. The data and models used in this study are available at https://github.com/grimme-lab/confrank.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to address the issue of conformation ranking in drug discovery. Specifically, it introduces a method called ConfRank, which is a machine learning-based approach that improves the accuracy of conformation ranking through pairwise training. The paper points out that traditional molecular dynamics methods are limited by the underlying force field calculations in terms of runtime and energy ranking accuracy, restricting their effectiveness in large-scale screening applications. The ConfRank method significantly improves overall conformation ranking by capturing the relative energy differences between two conformations rather than predicting the energy of a single molecule in isolation. Experimental results show that this method reduces the root mean square deviation (RMSD) of relative energy differences on the test dataset from 5.65 kcal/mol to 0.71 kcal/mol and can correctly identify up to 81% of the lowest energy conformations, whereas traditional methods like GFN-FF can only achieve 10%, and GFN2-xTB achieves 47%. Additionally, the paper theoretically demonstrates the advantages of the pairwise training method. Although this training approach may lead to a decrease in the performance of machine learning models in predicting the absolute energy of individual samples, it significantly enhances the performance of conformation ranking. The study results indicate that this method is not only cost-effective but also deployable on both CPU and GPU, accelerating by two orders of magnitude compared to GFN2-xTB. Furthermore, the method also shows good robustness in out-of-sample testing, proving its effectiveness across different datasets.

ConfRank: Improving GFN-FF Conformer Ranking with Pairwise Training

Toward Reliable Conformational Energies of Amino Acids and Dipeptides─The DipCONFS Benchmark and DipCONL Datasets

Improved Protein–Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction with Structure-Based Deep Fusion Inference

ConfGen: A Conformational Search Method for Efficient Generation of Bioactive Conformers

TorsionNet: A Reinforcement Learning Approach to Sequential Conformer Search

Learning Over Molecular Conformer Ensembles: Datasets and Benchmarks

An optimization algorithm for conformer generation based on the bond contribution ranking

Rrcrank: A Fusion Method Using Rank Strategy for Residue-Residue Contact Prediction

Moltiverse: Molecular Conformer Generation Using Enhanced Sampling Methods

CoarsenConf: Equivariant Coarsening with Aggregated Attention for Molecular Conformer Generation

May the Force be with You: Unified Force-Centric Pre-Training for 3D Molecular Conformations

Conf-GEM: a geometric information-assisted direct conformation generation model

Conformalized Graph Learning for Molecular ADMET Property Prediction and Reliable Uncertainty Quantification.

Leveraging 2D molecular graph pretraining for improved 3D conformer generation with graph neural networks

Learning Gradient Fields for Molecular Conformation Generation

Small-Molecule Conformer Generators: Evaluation of Traditional Methods and AI Models on High-Quality Data Sets

DeepConf: Leveraging ANI-ML Potentials for Exploring Local Minima with A Focus on Bioactive Conformations

ET-Flow: Equivariant Flow-Matching for Molecular Conformer Generation

Pre‐Training of Equivariant Graph Matching Networks with Conformation Flexibility for Drug Binding

Conformer selection and induced fit in flexible backbone protein-protein docking using computational and NMR ensembles

An Analysis of Proteochemometric and Conformal Prediction Machine Learning Protein-Ligand Binding Affinity Models