Abstract:It was discovered several decades ago that eddy covariance measurements systematically underestimate sensible and latent heat fluxes, creating an imbalance in the surface energy budget. Since then, many studies have addressed this problem and proposed a variety of solutions to the problem, including improvements to instruments and correction methods applied during data postprocessing. However, none of these measures have led to the complete closure of the energy balance gap. The leading hypothesis is that not only surface-attached turbulent eddies but also sub-mesoscale atmospheric circulations contribute to the transport of energy in the atmospheric boundary layer, and the contribution from organized motions has been grossly neglected. The problem arises because the transport of energy through these secondary circulations cannot be captured by the standard eddy covariance method given the relatively short averaging periods of time (~30 minutes) used to compute statistics. There are various approaches to adjust the measured heat fluxes by attributing the missing energy to the sensible and latent heat flux in different proportions. However, few correction methods are based on the processes causing the energy balance gap. Several studies have shown that the magnitude of the energy balance gap depends on the atmospheric stability and the heterogeneity scale of the landscape around the measurement site. Based on this, the energy balance gap within the surface layer has already been modelled as a function of a nonlocal atmospheric stability parameter by performing a large-eddy simulation study with idealized homogeneous surfaces. We have further developed this approach by including thermal surface heterogeneity in addition to atmospheric stability in the parameterization. Specifically, we incorporated a thermal heterogeneity parameter that was shown to relate to the magnitude of the energy balance gap. For this purpose, we use a Large-Eddy Simulation dataset of 28 simulations with seven different atmospheric conditions and three heterogeneous surfaces with different heterogeneity scales as well as one homogeneous surface. The newly developed model captures very well the variability in the magnitude of the energy balance gap under different conditions. The model covers a wide range of both atmospheric stabilities and landscape heterogeneity scales and is well suited for application to eddy covariance measurements since all necessary information can be modelled or obtained from a few additional measurements.

Implications of Energy Balance Non-Closure on Carbon Dioxide Flux Uncertainties: Insights from Large Eddy Simulations in Convective Boundary Layers

Mechanistic Links Between Underestimated CO 2 Fluxes and Non-Closure of the Surface Energy Balance in a Semi-Arid Sagebrush Ecosystem

Scalar Flux Profiles in the Unstable Atmospheric Surface Layer under the Influence of Large Eddies: Implications for Eddy Covariance Flux Measurements and the Non‐Closure Problem

Consequences of Incomplete Surface Energy Balance Closure for CO2 Fluxes from Open-Path CO2/H2O Infrared Gas Analysers

Non‐Closure of Surface Energy Balance Linked to Asymmetric Turbulent Transport of Scalars by Large Eddies

Non-closure of the surface energy balance explained by phase difference between vertical velocity and scalars of large atmospheric eddies

Enlarged Nonclosure of Surface Energy Balance with Increasing Atmospheric Instabilities Linked to Changes in Coherent Structures

How Does Turbulent Organized Structure Influence Surface Energy Balance Closure? A Study Utilizing Large-Eddy Simulation

Large Eddies Modulating Flux Convergence and Divergence in a Disturbed Unstable Atmospheric Surface Layer

Incorporating the effect of heterogeneous surface heating into a semi-empirical model of the surface energy balance closure.

Towards Energy-Balance Closure with a Model of Dispersive Heat Fluxes

Characterizing energy balance closure over a heterogeneous ecosystem using multi-tower eddy covariance

The Underestimation of the Turbulent Fluxes in Eddy Correlation Techniques

Calculating Canopy Stomatal Conductance from Eddy Covariance Measurements, in Light of the Energy Budget Closure Problem

Influence of nonlocal advection on surface fluxes over a vegetated surface : evidence from ebex 2000 field data

Assessing the Performance of Flux Imbalance Prediction Models Using Large Eddy Simulations Over Heterogeneous Land Surfaces

Diurnal Variations of the Flux Imbalance over Homogeneous and Heterogeneous Landscapes

Water Flux Characterization Through Hydraulic Head and Temperature Data Assimilation: Numerical Modeling and Sandbox Experiments

Effects of Vegetative Heterogeneity and Patch-Scale Harvest on Energy Balance Closure and Flux Measurements

Intrinsic Constraints on Asymmetric Turbulent Transport of Scalars Within the Constant Flux Layer of the Lower Atmosphere

Large-eddy-model closure and simulation of turbulent flux patterns over oasis surface