Abstract:This paper investigates whether online recommendation of products that exhibit corporate social responsibility (CSR) penalizes the purchase intention of non-CSR products. When consumers browse online retail stores and consider buying a particular product, online recommendation is made (e.g., “Customers who viewed this item also viewed”). This recommendation is often made between products of which attributes have a trade-off relationship (e.g., CSR vs. price). (A trade-off is where one thing increases, and another must decrease. A trade-off relationship between CSR and price suggests a pair of competing products are available: a more expensive, CSR product and an economical, non-CSR product.) We borrowed from the psychological literature of evaluability to hypothesize that when a CSR product is recommended, consumers would decrease their purchase intention of the economical product. However, when an economical product is recommended, consumers would maintain their purchase intention of the CSR product. We further hypothesized that this asymmetric effect would disappear when reinforcement information regarding the CSR is provided. Two carefully designed experiments conducted in China supported these hypotheses. Our findings contribute to the growing literature on online retailers by elucidating the psychological impact of online recommendations, which may influence manufacturers’ sales in an unexpected manner. The findings also indicate that online recommendations could be a potential source of channel conflict. While this study newly verifies the unintended CSR violation effect of online recommendations, future studies are required to expand our understanding of the CSR violation effect by investigating the effect under the trade-off relationship with other attributes of the product.

Avoid Following Individual Shopping Time Habit to Promote New Products: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment

Investigating the effects of product popularity and time restriction: The moderating role of consumers' goal specificity

How do product recommendations affect impulse buying? An empirical study on WeChat social commerce

Targeted Promotions and Cross-Category Spillover Effects

Early Bird Versus Late Owl: an Empirical Investigation of Individual Shopping Time Habits and Its Effects

Effects of Product Portfolios and Recommendation Timing in the Efficiency of Personalized Recommendation

Unintended CSR Violation Caused by Online Recommendation

Making Recommendations Better: The Role of User Online Purchase Intention Identification

The Searching Artificial Intelligence: Consumers Show Less Aversion to Algorithm‐recommended Search Product

Effect Of Timing And Source Of Online Product Recommendations: An Eye-Tracking Study

Impact of recommender systems on unplanned purchase behaviours in e-commerce

Immediate and Continued Effects of App Real-Time Targeting along Customer Shopping Journey: A Field Experiment

Does the Product Recommendation Really Promote the Purchase Decision? Research on the Influence of Recommended Timing on Purchase Deferral

Assessing the Impact of Recommendation Novelty on Older Consumers: Older Does Not Always Mean the Avoidance of Innovative Products

Can the Love for Promotional Offering Be Easily Substituted? Impact of Promotional Out-of-Stock of New Products on Consumer's Response to Recommendation of Similar Alternatives

Study on the Influencing Factors of Unplanned Consumption in a Large Online Promotion Activity

Effect of Product Type and Time Pressure on Consumers' Online Impulse Buying Intention

Is Time-Constrained Promotion Actually Effective the Moderating Role of Price Discounts and Previous Online Consumption Experience

Drivers of Purchase Behavior and Post-Purchase Evaluation in the Singles' Day Promotion

Do We Care What Others Get? A Behaviorist Approach to Targeted Promotions

The Impact of Exposure to Nature on Consumers’ Willingness to Wait