Cooperative Control of Air Flow for HVAC Systems - Escholarship
Shuai Liu,Baocang Ding
2013-01-01
Abstract:Cooperative Control of Air Flow for HVAC Systems Shuai Liu 1,2 , Yushen Long 1 , Lihua Xie 1 and Alexandre M. Bayen 3 Abstract— A dynamic pressure and variable air volume (VAV) control strategy is proposed for building heating, ven- tilation and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems. The strategy consists in two level control, namely, pressure loop control and temperature loop control. The pressure control loop is to make sure that the air pressure at the inlet of each room is equal to a certain value while the temperature control loop is to control the room temperature which is achieved by adjusting the VAV box so that the supply air flow rate can be varied to achieve the room setting temperature. For the pressure control loop, a cooperative control technique is applied. The two control loops are coupled. This paper will analyze the stability of the overall system and give a sufficient condition on the initial values in terms of rooms and the HVAC system parameters. I. I NTRODUCTION In recent years, energy saving and environment protection have become increasingly important. The world’s growing energy demand requires developing sustainable living plans. The largest sector of energy consumption in most of cities is buildings. Usually, a great portion of the energy consumption of buildings is attributed to HVAC systems. Due to the changes of operating environment and parameters of HVAC systems, many HVAC systems cannot work in an efficient way. Therefore, the controller design of HVAC systems is a field of increasing significance. HVAC systems can be controlled based on either static models assuming that the environment is slowly time-varying or dynamic models for real-time control. Most of the existing work on controller design is based on static models [14], and mainly focused on developing a simplified model of cooling coils. The model parameters are determined on-line, based on commission or catalog information by linear or nonlinear least squares methods. For overall HVAC systems, [4] and [5] formulate the minimization of the total power consumption, which is mainly caused by chillers, pumps and fans, as a global optimization problem. A modified genetic algorithm was used to set the optimal operating point of each component. When we consider the dynamic property of an HVAC system, the control problem becomes more difficult. A new dynamic simulation model for air-handling unit (AHU) was developed in [2]. In the work, the parameters 1 Shuai Liu, Lihua Xie and Yushen Long are with EXQUISI- TUS, Centre for E-City, School of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 639798 {lius0025,elhxie,YLONG002} at ntu.edu.sg 2 Shuai Liu is with SinBerBEST Program, Berkeley Education Alliance for Research in Singapore, CREATE Tower, Singapore 138602 liushuai at ntu.edu.sg 3 A. M. Bayen is with the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences, and Department of Civil and Environmental Engi- neering, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720 USA bayen at berkeley.edu can be easily determined from total fan energy measurement. Since dynamic models can handle the changing environment at different times in a day over a long period of time, a dynamic control strategy can lead to a better performance compared to a static control strategy. By using Kalman filtering, [11] presents a temperature prediction algorithm based on a simple time varying zone model. The optimal performance is achieved by applying a genetic algorithm. Room temperature can be controlled by adjusting the cool air temperature and flow rate into a room, which is controlled by a damper. There are two temperature control strate- gies: pressure dependent control and pressure independent control. Pressure dependent control consists in controlling the damper, based on the room temperature. Based on the temperature difference between the room temperature and the desired one, one can adjust the air flow by controlling the VAV box. The reader can refer to [12], [15], [1], [8] and [7] for example. Pressure independent control strategies contain two control loops. The inner loop is for temperature control which can provide the set point for outer loop based on the temperature difference. The outer loop is for air pressure control. Pressure independent control leads to better control performance. This is because a pressure dependent controller will take action when the air flow changes affect the room temperature. Therefore the response of the system suffers from a time delay. However, pressure independent control has a pressure control level which is to lock the pressure at the inlet of each room. The steady air pressure makes the air flow rate smooth. Moreover, the two level control makes the controller design more flexible. In this paper, we consider a pressure independent control strategy. Keeping the air pressure of the room inlet is the key step to air flow control. However, when adjusting a damper, not only the air pressure at the corresponding branch changes, but the pressure at all the other branches are affected. For the pressure control loop, a cooperative control strategy is developed to adjust the damper such that the air pressure of each branch converges to a desired value. The cooperative controller can reduce the pressure differences among each room inlet while tracking the desired pressure, which makes the tracking process smoother. Moreover, the controller is working in a distributed way, which means each pressure control damper is controlled based only on the pressure information of neighbor branches. Comparing with a centralized controller, the distributed one is more reliable and has low computation costs.