Rethinking Polyiodides: The Role of Electron-Deficient Multicenter Bonds

Matteo Savastano,Hussien H. Osman,Ángel Vegas,Francisco Javier Manjón Herrera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-5w7wp

2024-08-12

Abstract:Despite a bicentennial history, the interest in polyiodides and related systems still flourishes. The chemical puzzle provided by the intricate nature of chemical bonding in these polyanions remains challenging these days. The advent of the halogen bond and the spreading interest in supramolecular interactions of halogen-based systems promoted further recent interest. Research in the area of materials, where local bonding details eventually result in desired macroscopic properties, provided a further boost. Herein, we illustrate the consequences of contemplating a different bonding scheme for polyiodides, one making explicit use of electron-deficient multicenter bonds (EDMBs), an emerging concept in this area. We present a reinterpretation of polyiodide bonding using a revised approach to the Lewis dot formulas, leading to a clearer pen-and-paper understanding of their bonding. The model is general and can be applied to other related problems (here polyiodonium cations, other homo- and hetero-polyhalides). Our alternative narrative has a few interesting consequences on several traditional and currently hot topics, including the nature of basic building blocks for polyiodides, hypervalency vs. hypercoordination, the distinction between covalent bonds and supramolecular interactions, and the nature of secondary and halogen bonds.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the chemical bonding characteristics of polyiodides and proposes a new explanatory method, namely using Electron-Deficient Multicenter Bonds (EDMBs) to reinterpret the chemical bonds in polyiodides. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following core issues:

1. **Problems with traditional explanations**: Polyiodides have been known for over 200 years, but their complex chemical bonding properties remain controversial. Particularly, for phenomena that violate the octet rule, the mainstream explanation usually considers them as hypervalent species involving three-center four-electron (3c-4e) bonds. However, this explanation has been challenged both experimentally and theoretically.

2. **New understanding of supramolecular interactions**: The paper discusses recent criticisms of supramolecular interaction models (such as secondary bonds, halogen bonds, etc.) and suggests the need to reconstruct a coherent perspective to understand these interactions.

3. **New understanding of linear multicenter bonds**: Recent studies have shown that even for electron-rich elements (such as iodine), linear multicenter bonds involving more than three atoms must be electron-deficient types (i.e., 2c-1e EDMB). This finding prompts researchers to reconsider the chemical bonds in polyiodides.

4. **Reinterpretation of polyiodides**: By introducing a revised version of the Lewis dot structure, the paper proposes a new method to explain the chemical bonds and geometric structures in polyiodides. This method can more clearly demonstrate the chemical bonding characteristics in polyiodides and help understand the distinction between hypervalent and hypercoordinate species, the boundary between covalent bonds and supramolecular interactions, and the nature of secondary and halogen bonds.

5. **Prediction of stability, bending, and bond length alternation**: The paper also demonstrates how to use simple pen-and-paper methods to predict the stability, bending, and bond length alternation of linear chain polyiodides based on the following concepts: Lewis dot structure, octet rule, Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) theory, and specific types of chemical bonds (single covalent 2c-2e bonds, 3c-4e bonds, extended 2c-1e EDMB).

In summary, the core of the paper lies in proposing a new perspective to understand the complex chemical bonding properties in polyiodides and supporting this new viewpoint through a revised version of the Lewis dot structure.