A Pathway Analysis Framework for Evaluating the Economic and Environmental Viability of Biomass-Based Plastic Production

Bo-Xun Wang,Jiqing Zhuang,Victor Zavala

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-m37vq

2024-08-09

Abstract:Plastic production from fossil feedstocks (e.g., naphtha, coal, natural gas) is not sustainable and causes known environmental impacts such as global warming. A possible solution is to shift production pathways to use biomass, which is a sustainable feedstock and can sequester armo- spheric carbon dioxide. This study presents an optimization-based pathway analysis framework for evaluating the carbon footprints of the production of mainstream plastics from biomass and fossil feedstocks. We use the modeling framework to quickly navigate complex interdependen- cies that exist between the production pathways of different plastics and to determine pathways of minimum production cost under a range of carbon pricing scenarios. The framework interprets carbon prices as an exogenous taxation scheme or as an endogenous negative value perceived by producers. The proposed approach reveals biomass feedstock quantities needed to displace fossil counterparts and reveals plastics and technologies that should be prioritized. The frame- work can also be used for evaluating system-wide trade-offs between production costs and carbon footprints that arise from pathway interdependencies. We also evaluate hidden environmental impacts associated with the large-scale use biomass as a feedstock, such as land use and water eutrophication that results from significant increase in fertilizer use. The proposed framework provides an integrative platform for basic techno-economic and life-cycle data that can be used for analyzing diverse scenarios and for determining necessary technologies targets (e.g., yields, footprints, and costs) to achieve required levels of decarbonization.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to evaluate and optimize the economic and environmental feasibility of producing plastics from biomass raw materials to replace traditional fossil fuel raw materials and achieve the decarbonization of plastic production**.

Specifically, the author proposes an optimization - based path analysis framework for evaluating the carbon footprint of producing mainstream plastics from biomass and fossil fuel raw materials and determining the lowest - cost production - path under different carbon - pricing scenarios. The following are the main objectives of this study:

1. **Evaluate carbon footprint**: Navigate the complex dependencies between different plastic production paths quickly through the modeling framework to evaluate their carbon footprint.
2. **Determine the lowest - cost path**: Find the optimal path that minimizes production costs under different carbon - pricing scenarios.
3. **Reveal technology priorities**: Determine which plastics and technologies should be given priority to achieve different degrees of decarbonization.
4. **Evaluate systemic trade - offs**: Analyze the trade - off between production costs and carbon footprint, as well as the hidden environmental impacts (such as land use and water eutrophication) that may be brought about by the large - scale use of biomass as a raw material.

Through these objectives, this study aims to provide an integrated techno - economic and life - cycle data platform for policymakers and the industry, helping to analyze different scenarios and determine the technological goals (such as output, footprint, and cost) required to achieve the desired decarbonization level.