Abstract:From a passive satellite remote sensing point of view, the richest set of information on aerosol properties can be obtained from instruments that measure both intensity and polarization of backscattered sunlight at multiple wavelengths and multiple viewing angles for one ground pixel. However, it is challenging to exploit this information at a global scale because complex algorithms are needed with many fit parameters (aerosol and land/ocean reflection), based on online radiative transfer models. So far, two such algorithms have demonstrated this capability at a global scale: the Generalized Retrieval of Atmosphere and Surface Properties (GRASP) algorithm and the Remote sensing of Trace gas and Aerosol Products (RemoTAP) algorithm. In this paper, we present a detailed comparison of the most recent versions of RemoTAP and GRASP. We evaluate both algorithms for synthetic observations, for real PARASOL (Polarization and Anisotropy of Reflectances for Atmospheric Science coupled with Observations from a Lidar) observations against AERONET (Aerosol Robotic Network) for common pixels, and for global PARASOL retrievals for the year 2008. For the aerosol optical depth (AOD) over land, both algorithms show a root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.10 (at 550 nm). For single scattering albedo (SSA), both algorithms show a good performance in terms of RMSE (0.04), but RemoTAP has a smaller bias (0.002) compared to GRASP (0.021). For the Ångström exponent (AE), GRASP has a smaller RMSE (0.367) than RemoTAP (0.387), mainly caused by a small overestimate of AE at low values (large particles). Over ocean both algorithms perform very well. For AOD, RemoTAP has an RMSE of 0.057 and GRASP an even smaller RMSE of 0.047. For AE, the RMSEs of RemoTAP and GRASP are 0.285 and 0.224, respectively. Based on the AERONET comparison, we conclude that both algorithms show very similar overall performance, where both algorithms have stronger and weaker points. For the global data products, we find a root mean square difference (RMSD) between RemoTAP and GRASP AOD of 0.12 and 0.038 over land and ocean, respectively. The largest differences occur over the biomass burning region in equatorial Africa. The global mean values are virtually unbiased with respect to each other. For AE the RMSD between RemoTAP and GRASP is 0.33 over land and 0.23 over ocean. For SSA, we find much better agreement over land (bias = − 0.01, RMSD = 0.043 for retrievals with AOD > 0.2) than over ocean (bias = 0.053, RMSD = 0.074). As expected, the differences increase towards low AOD, over both land and ocean. We also compared the GRASP and RemoTAP AOD and AE products against MODIS. For AOD over land, the agreement of either GRASP or RemoTAP with MODIS is worse than the agreement between the two PARASOL algorithms themselves. Over ocean, the agreement is very similar among the three products for AOD. For AE, the agreement between GRASP and RemoTAP is much better than the agreement of both products with MODIS. The agreement of the latest product versions with each other and with AERONET improved significantly compared to the previous version of the global products of GRASP and RemoTAP. The results demonstrate that the dedicated effort in algorithm development for multi-angle polarimetric (MAP) aerosol retrievals still leads to substantial improvement of the resulting aerosol products, and this is still an ongoing process.

Machine Learning Based Aerosol and Ocean Color Joint Retrieval Algorithm for Multiangle Polarimeters over Coastal Waters

Efficient multi-angle polarimetric inversion of aerosols and ocean color powered by a deep neural network forward model

Inversion of multiangular polarimetric measurements from the ACEPOL campaign: an application of improving aerosol property and hyperspectral ocean color retrievals

Inversion of Multiangular Polarimetric Measurements over Open and Coastal Ocean Waters: a Joint Retrieval Algorithm for Aerosol and Water-Leaving Radiance Properties

Adaptive Data Screening for Multi-Angle Polarimetric Aerosol and Ocean Color Remote Sensing Accelerated by Deep Learning

Simultaneous retrieval of aerosol and ocean properties from PACE HARP2 with uncertainty assessment using cascading neural network radiative transfer models

The PACE-MAPP Algorithm: Simultaneous Aerosol and Ocean Polarimeter Products Using Coupled Atmosphere-Ocean Vector Radiative Transfer

Effective uncertainty quantification for multi-angle polarimetric aerosol remote sensing over ocean

Effective uncertainty quantification for multi-angle polarimetric aerosol remote sensing over ocean, Part 1: performance evaluation and speed improvement

Performance evaluation of three bio-optical models in aerosol and ocean color joint retrievals

Atmospheric Correction over the Ocean for Hyperspectral Radiometers Using Multi-Angle Polarimetric Retrievals.

Retrieval of Aerosol Properties and Water-Leaving Reflectance from Multi-Angular Polarimetric Measurements over Coastal Waters.

Simultaneous Polarimeter Retrievals of Microphysical Aerosol and Ocean Color Parameters from the "MAPP" Algorithm with Comparison to High-Spectral-resolution Lidar Aerosol and Ocean Products

Atmospheric correction of ocean color imagery: use of the junge power-law aerosol size distribution with variable refractive index to handle aerosol absorption

Atmospheric Correction for Coastal Waters Based on Multi-Angle Polarimetric Observations

A robust and flexible satellite aerosol retrieval algorithm for multi-angle polarimetric measurements with physics-informed deep learning method

Atmospheric Correction of Satellite Ocean-Color Imagery During the PACE Era

Retrieval of Aerosol Optical Properties over a Vegetation Surface Using Multi-Angular, Multi-Spectral, and Polarized Data

A Radiative Transfer Simulator for PACE: Theory and Applications

Algorithm evaluation for polarimetric remote sensing of atmospheric aerosols

Machine Learning Based Retrieval of Aerosol and Surface Properties over Land from the Gaofen-5 Directional Polarimetric Camera Measurements