Photocatalysis of Viologen-radical-driven Hydrogen Evolution from Water Using Macrocyclic Co-NHC Catalysts: Volmer-Heyrovsky-like Two-step CPET Pathway in Molecular Catalysis

Kosei Yamauchi,Ken Kawano,Koichi Yatsuzuka,Ken Sakai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-lnz4f

2024-07-30

Abstract:The factors controlling the catalytic activity in photochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) are studied in detail for two macrocyclic cobalt compounds bearing two N-heterocyclic carbenes and two pyridyl donors (Co-NHC1 and Co-NHC2, where Co-NHC2 has a methoxy substituent on each pyridyl ligand). The present study adopts an aqueous photosystem consisting of EDTA, [Ru(bpy)3]2+ (bpy = 2,2’-bipyridine), and MV2+ (MV2+ = methylviologen) at pH = 5. Both catalysts are shown to promote HER in a similar efficiency (TON = 12-13 in 6 h), revealing a minor contribution of the electron-donating methoxy substituents. The catalyst degradation is shown to proceed during the photocatalysis, leading to afford [Co(edta)]− (EDTA = H4edta) as a dead-end species. The lack of any heterogeneous species was evidenced by DLS (dynamic light scattering). It was also found that nitrate involved as a counter anion in the photocatalysis components substantially inhibits the photocatalytic HER, giving rise to a large diminishment in TON from 12.7 to 7.2. The Griess test was used to confirm that NO3− serves as a scavenger deactivating the reduced form of MV2+ (i.e., MV+•). The detailed spectroscopic study reveals that the diradical (MV+•)2 species plays a key role in promoting the one-step two-electron process: (MV+•)2 + NO3− + 2H+ → 2MV2+ + NO2− + H2O. Our DFT results also reveal that a unique double CPET (concerted proton-electron transfer) pathway is taken to evolve H2 by the Co-NHC catalysts with substantially minimized reorganization energies: Co(II)-NHC → Co(III)(H)-NHC → Co(II)-NHC + H2. This pathway can be viewed as related to the so-called Volmer-Heyrovsky mechanism adopted by some metals and is quite unique to the Co-NHC catalysts.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily focuses on the process of hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) from water under photocatalytic conditions using specific cobalt-based catalysts (Co-NHC1 and Co-NHC2). Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Factors Affecting Catalyst Activity**: The study investigated the activity differences when using two cobalt compounds containing N-heterocyclic carbene ligands (Co-NHC1 and Co-NHC2) as catalysts. The results indicated that the methoxy substituent had a minimal impact on catalytic efficiency.

2. **Catalyst Degradation Process**: It was found that the catalyst undergoes degradation during the photocatalytic process, producing [Co(edta)]− as the final product. Dynamic light scattering experiments confirmed that no heterogeneous species were formed.

3. **Effect of Nitrate Ions**: Nitrate ions (NO₃⁻) significantly inhibited the photocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction. The Griess test confirmed that NO₃⁻ could act as a scavenger, reacting with MV⁺• to form nitrite ions (NO₂⁻), thereby inhibiting hydrogen production.

4. **Unique Dual CPET Mechanism**: Density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed a unique dual concerted proton-electron transfer (CPET) pathway, namely:
\[
\text{Co(II)-NHC} \xrightarrow{\text{CPET}} \text{Co(III)(H)-NHC} \xrightarrow{\text{CPET}} \text{Co(II)-NHC + H₂}
\]
This mechanism is similar to the traditional Volmer-Heyrovsky mechanism but has a lower reorganization energy.

In summary, the paper aims to further optimize the design of catalysts and improve their catalytic efficiency by thoroughly studying various influencing factors in the photocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction.