Ex situ electro-organic synthesis: A method to decouple electro- and thermochemical steps for unrestricted reaction control

Dominik P. Halter,Helena Pletsch,Yang Lyu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-d4qlr

2024-07-10

Abstract:Classic in situ electro-organic synthesis with substrates added into electrolyzers often suffers from poor efficiency and restricted product selectivity tuning possibilities. The reason is that electrolysis conditions must balance requirements of both electro- and thermochemical steps during electrocatalytic reaction cascades, and additionally compromise between paired anode and cathode reactions. Hence, selective and efficient electrosynthesis remains challenging for many products, and particularly for economic co-production of anodic and cathodic products. Herein, we exemplify the method of ex situ electro-organic synthesis as an option to break such traditional compatibility barriers. The two-step process platform separates electrochemical catalyst activation steps in time and space from thermochemical substrate conversion at the activated catalyst. Thereby, ex situ electro-organic synthesis enables independent tuning of electrochemistry and organic synthesis for unique selectivity. For proof-of-concept, we demonstrate this using redox energy storage in Ni(OH)2/NiOOH anodes for selective alcohol oxidation. Specifically, in a two-step process, first bulk oxidation of Ni(OH)2 electrodes to NiOOH material is paired to H2 production by alkaline water electrolysis. Then, “charged” NiOOH electrodes are removed from the electrolyzer and used in external vessels to exemplarily oxidize benzyl alcohol under regeneration of Ni(OH)2 for another run. Free choice of reaction medium allows to convert benzyl alcohol either to benzoic acid with 99% selectivity (in water) or to benzaldehyde with 91% selectivity (in n-hexane), where classic in situ electrolysis can only produce the acid together with H2. Since NiOOH can mediate many organic conversions, this work may inspire future electro-synthesis of several previously inaccessible products.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses a new method called "Ex situ electro-organic synthesis" to address the efficiency and selectivity limitations in classical in situ electro-organic synthesis. In the traditional approach, the electrochemical and thermochemical steps need to be carried out simultaneously in the electrolytic cell, which restricts the adjustment of reaction conditions and results in low selectivity and efficiency. The researchers achieved independent adjustment of electrochemistry and organic synthesis by separating the electrochemical catalyst activation step from thermal substrate conversion in time and space, thereby improving selectivity.

Specifically, they demonstrated a two-step process using Ni(OH)2/NiOOH as an example. Firstly, Ni(OH)2 was oxidized to NiOOH by mild anodic voltage while simultaneously generating hydrogen gas from water. Then, the "charged" NiOOH electrode was taken out from the electrolytic cell and the selective oxidation of benzyl alcohol was performed in an external container to regenerate Ni(OH)2 for the next cycle. With this method, 99% benzonic acid or 91% benzaldehyde can be selectively obtained in different solvents, whereas traditional in situ electrolysis can only produce benzonic acid and hydrogen gas.

The paper also mentions that NiOOH can catalyze various organic transformations, thus this method may inspire electro-synthesis of previously difficult-to-obtain products in the future. Experimental results show that the Ni(OH)2/NiOOH electrode exhibits good repeatability and selectivity under different conditions, providing a new strategy for electro-organic synthesis, especially for product combinations that are difficult to achieve in traditional methods.