Abstract:Land consolidation (LC) is considered an effective instrument to respond to public demands in rural areas of China due to its evolution from a purely technical policy into a more comprehensive social project. As one of the most important steps in LC, land adjustment has a major impact on its success. Despite the broad heterogeneity of local contexts, land adjustment-related collective action has emerged nationwide as a public good. However, the generalized patterns explaining how and why such examples of local collective action occur remain poorly investigated. This study analyses configurations of the factors that generate land adjustment-related collective action in LC by drawing upon the archetype approach and using a social-ecological systems (SES) framework to conceptually decompose the many details of cases. Based on 34 systematically selected cases from eastern, central, and western China, the results show that there is a set of 23 configurations of factors that bear a causal relationship with collective action in land adjustment. These can be clustered into six archetypes. Some collective action conditions that are well known in the existing literature, such as group size, reciprocity, and trust, are reconfirmed in this analysis. Furthermore, several distinctive implications are drawn from the archetype analysis: 1) Local leadership combined with self-governance convention and institutionalized self-organization or powerful local leadership allied with goal congruence create favorable conditions for the local collective action of self-organized LCPs. 2) Leadership also plays a significant role in facilitating local collective action for land adjustment under government-led and enterprise-led modes as government and enterprises rely on local leadership to avoid the need to contact numerous scattered farmers and to save on transaction costs. 3) While excessive intervention by the government is restrained under self-organized and enterprise-led modes, the archetypes highlight that government participation facilitate local cooperation. 4) The government and enterprises likely engage in rural collective action through divergent mechanisms motivated by their political or economic goals. In general, these findings provide new insights into land-related local collective action and may benefit China and other regions for transition processes towards rural sustainability.

Land Reallocation and Collective Action in the Commons: Application of Social-Ecological System Framework with Evidence from Rural China

The Micro Administrative Mechanism of Land Reallocation in Land Consolidation: A Perspective from Collective Action

The Effects of Land Reallocation on Irrigation Collective Action: Moderating Effects of Informal Organizations and Leadership

The Impacts of Land Fragmentation on Irrigation Collective Action: Empirical Test of the Social-Ecological System Framework in China

Collective Participation in Conservation Easements in Rural China: Evidence from the Qianjiangyuan National Park

A behavioral analysis of farmers during land reallocation processes of land consolidation in China: Insights from Guangxi and Shandong provinces

Effects of Farmland Use Rights Transfer on Collective Action in the Commons: Evidence from Rural China

The effects of socialized agricultural services on rural collective action in the irrigation commons: Evidence from China

Farmland Titling, Farmland Adjustment and Rural Collective Action: Application of Institutional Analysis and Development Framework Using Evidence from China's Irrigation Commons

How physical and social factors affect village-level irrigation: An institutional analysis of water governance in northern China

The Suitability and Sustainability of Governance Structures in Land Consolidation under Institutional Change: A Comparative Case Study

Collective land system in China: Congenital flaw or acquired irrational weakness?

Emergence of Local Collective Action for Land Adjustment in Land Consolidation in China: an Archetype Analysis

The effects of farmland use rights trading and labor outmigration on the governance of the irrigation commons: Evidence from China

Effects of Land Fragmentation on the Governance of the Commons: Theory and Evidence from 284 Villages and 17 Provinces in China

Migration and collective action in the commons: application of social-ecological system framework with evidence from China

Collective action dilemmas of sustainable natural resource management: A case study on land marketization in rural China

The Dilemma of Land Expansion and Governance in Rural China: A Comparative Study Based on Three Townships in Zhejiang Province

The Effects of Migration on Collective Action in the Commons: Evidence from Rural China

The mediated effects of urban proximity on collective action in the commons: Theory and evidence from China

Collective Action in Implementing Top-Down Land Policy: the Case of Chengdu, China