Comparison and Optimal Method of Detecting the Number of Maize Seedlings Based on Deep Learning
Zhijie Jia,Xinlong Zhang,Hongye Yang,Yuan Lu,Jiale Liu,Xun Yu,Dayun Feng,Kexin Gao,Jianfu Xue,Bo Ming,Chenwei Nie,Shaokun Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/drones8050175
IF: 5.532
2024-01-01
Drones
Abstract:Effective agricultural management in maize production operations starts with the early quantification of seedlings. Accurately determining plant presence allows growers to optimize planting density, allocate resources, and detect potential growth issues early on. This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the performance of various object detection models in maize production, with a focus on the effects of planting density, growth stages, and flight altitudes. The findings of this study demonstrate that one-stage models, particularly YOLOv8n and YOLOv5n, demonstrated superior performance with AP50 scores of 0.976 and 0.951, respectively, outperforming two-stage models in terms of resource efficiency and seedling quantification accuracy. YOLOv8n, along with Deformable DETR, Faster R-CNN, and YOLOv3-tiny, were identified for further examination based on their performance metrics and architectural features. The study also highlights the significant impact of plant density and growth stage on detection accuracy. Increased planting density and advanced growth stages (particularly V6) were associated with decreased model accuracy due to increased leaf overlap and image complexity. The V2–V3 growth stages were identified as the optimal periods for detection. Additionally, flight altitude negatively affected image resolution and detection accuracy, with higher altitudes leading to poorer performance. In field applications, YOLOv8n proved highly effective, maintaining robust performance across different agricultural settings and consistently achieving rRMSEs below 1.64% in high-yield fields. The model also demonstrated high reliability, with Recall, Precision, and F1 scores exceeding 99.00%, affirming its suitability for practical agricultural use. These findings suggest that UAV-based image collection systems employing models like YOLOv8n can significantly enhance the accuracy and efficiency of seedling detection in maize production. The research elucidates the critical factors that impact the accuracy of deep learning detection models in the context of corn seedling detection and selects a model suited for this specific task in practical agricultural production. These findings offer valuable insights into the application of object detection technology and lay a foundation for the future development of precision agriculture, particularly in optimizing deep learning models for varying environmental conditions that affect corn seedling detection.