Abstract:The Trophic State Index (TSI), based on chlorophylla [TSI(Chla)], Secchi depth [TSI(SD)], total nitrogen [TSI(TN)], and total phosphorus [TSI(TP)], is a popular tool for lake eutrophication assessment worldwide, higher TSI scores implicitly indicate increased intensity of algal blooms. However, the application of TSI across diverse lakes may be questionable since the precondition of SD, TN, and TP as indicators of algal blooms lies in the fact that SD is dominated by algal turbidity; Chla in all lakes respond the same (or very similarly) to changes in TN (or TP) concentrations. Herein, 120 natural lakes and artificial reservoirs with a wide range of morphological, physicochemical, and Chla variables in the Chinese Eastern Plains ecoregion were collected via data mining to elaborate the utility of TSI on a regional scale. Moreover, we analyzed the source of uncertainties of TSI(SD), TSI(TN), and TSI(TP) in indicating algal biomass. Our results demonstrated that the TSI(SD), TSI(TN), and TSI(TP) scores were different with those of the TSI(Chla) (approximately 10 scores deviations). Considering 10 scores represent a doubling in algal biomass, the direct use of TSI may cause the misestimation of algal blooms intensity and under- or over-protection of the lakes and reservoirs. Furthermore, our results revealed water depth (WD, m) is the key inner-regional factor affecting the accuracy of TSI(SD), TSI(TN), and TSI(TP) in indicating algal biomass. For one, WD was closely related to mass ratio of nitrogen to phosphorus (N:P) and non-algal light attenuation (NALA, m−1) in our study lakes and reservoirs (lnNALA = -0.70*lnWD + 1.02, P < 0.001, R2 = 0.59; lnN:P = 0.61*lnWD + 1.88, P < 0.001, R2 = 0.50). For another, Linear relationships of [TSI(Chla)-TSI(SD)] vs NALA (negative, P < 0.001), [TSI(Chla)-TSI(TN)] vs lnN:P (negative, P < 0.001), and [TSI(Chla)-TSI(TP)] vs lnN:P (positive, P < 0.001) were also found. Based on the above equations and results of algal limiting factors, we recommended that TSI(SD) and TSI(TP) should not be used in very shallow lakes (WD < 2 m), and TSI(TN) should be excluded from the eutrophication assessment if WD > 5 m in our study area. On a broader scale, empirical TN (or TP), Chla, and SD relationships of lakes in other ecoregions may also be affected by WD and other unmeasured factors (e.g., zooplankton grazing), the direct use of TSI may be problematical. Thus, this study provides essential information for developing accurate lake eutrophication assessments in both ours and other ecoregions.

Deciphering Eutrophication-Limiting Nutrients in Lakes: A Multiscale Analysis of Chinese Waters

Comparative Analysis of Machine Learning Methods for Prediction of Chlorophyll-a in a River with Different Hydrology Characteristics: A Case Study in Fuchun River, China

Establishment of Season-Specific Nutrient Thresholds and Analyses of the Effects of Nutrient Management in Eutrophic Lakes Through Statistical Machine Learning

Using Machine Learning to Reveal Seasonal Nutrient Dynamics and Their Impact on Chlorophyll-a Levels in Lake Ecosystems: A Focus on Nitrogen and Phosphorus

Utilizing Machine Learning Models to Grasp Water Quality Dynamic Changes in Lake Eutrophication Through Phytoplankton Parameters

Identification of driving factors for chlorophyll‐a in multi‐stable shallow lakes of China employing machine learning methods

Trend Analysis and Modeling of Nutrient Concentrations in a Preliminary Eutrophic Lake in China

Evaluation of Eutrophication in Freshwater Lakes: A New Non-Equilibrium Statistical Approach

A Probabilistic Method to Enhance Understanding of Nutrient Limitation Dynamics of Phytoplankton

Relationships Between Nutrient, Chlorophyll a and Secchi Depth in Lakes of the Chinese Eastern Plains Ecoregion: Implications for Eutrophication Management.

Quantifying the Dependence of Cyanobacterial Growth to Nutrient for the Eutrophication Management of Temperate-Subtropical Shallow Lakes

Water quality assessment in a large plateau lake in China from 2014 to 2021 with machine learning models: Implications for future water quality management

Source Identification and Prediction of Nitrogen and Phosphorus Pollution of Lake Taihu by an Ensemble Machine Learning Technique

A novel total phosphorus concentration retrieval method based on two-line classification in lakes and reservoirs across China

Remote Quantification of the Trophic Status of Chinese Lakes

Utility of Trophic State Index in Lakes and Reservoirs in the Chinese Eastern Plains Ecoregion: the Key Role of Water Depth

The Identification of Nutrient Limitations on Eutrophication in Dianchi Lake, China

Spatiotemporal Dynamic Analysis of Eutrophication Status Based on Machine Learning-Based Retrieval Algorithm: Case Study in Liangzi Lake, Hubei, China

Chlorophyll a Predictability and Relative Importance of Factors Governing Lake Phytoplankton at Different Timescales.

The magnitude and drivers of harmful algal blooms in China’s lakes and reservoirs: A national-scale characterization

Identifying factors influencing reservoir eutrophication using interpretable machine learning combined with shoreline morphology and landscape hydrological features: A case study of Danjiangkou Reservoir, China