Abstract:Objectives: Research on the deterrent effects of driving-under-the-influence (DUI) laws has been limited in China, which has criminalized drunk driving since May 2011 yet the effectiveness of this legislation remains unclear. Primary studies are needed to confirm whether government reports of reductions in DUI rates since then can indeed match changes in driver perceptions of DUI risk, and if so, be attributed to what specific components of the DUI legal environments. Based on the classical theory of deterrence and recent advances in differential deterrence, this study adopted a conjoint experiment from a previous US study that simulated the decisionmaking process of potential drinking drivers, and evaluated how DUI sanctions and enforcement practices contributed differentially to the three components of deterrence (i.e., certainty, swiftness, and severity of punishment). Key individual characteristics and nonlegal factors, as suggested by differential deterrence research to moderate the impact of DUI laws, were also considered. Methods: A Web-based conjoint experiment was conducted on a sample of 109 college students from two major universities in Shenzhen, China. Participants were randomly assigned to blocks of hypothetical scenarios composed of different levels of DUI enforcement and penalties, and asked to choose from a pair of scenarios each time, in which they were more likely to drink and drive. They also answered questions adapted from previous studies that measured key individual factors in relation to differential deterrence, such as informal sanction threat, moral inhibition, and personal and vicarious experiences with punishment. Such individual differences were accounted for in both a conventional two-level mixed logit aggregate model and a Hierarchical Bayes model. Results: Consistent with prior findings in Western countries, DUI enforcement intensity, was found to be the strongest deterrent to potential drinking drivers in China. License suspension, as an administrative punishment that can be swiftly implemented, was also effective in deterring the Chinese drivers, who however were much more likely to fear the revocation of their licenses rather than a 6-month suspension only. Meanwhile, they were notably deterred by the possibility of being in jail for 1-3 days, let alone for 1-2 months. Altogether, enforcement, license suspension and jail penalties accounted for more than 75 percent of attribute impact on drivers' decision to drink and drive, whereas fine penalty and license points had almost no effect. On the other hand, nonlegal factors such as informal sanction threat and vicarious experiences were found to have significantly moderated the deterrent effects of DUI laws. Conclusions: Overall, this study quantified the unique effects of perceived certainty, swiftness, and severity of DUI punishment in the Chinese context, and supported the usefulness of conjoint experiments for examining risk perceptions and DUI decisions in different legal environments. It also provided new empirical evidence on differential deterrence and pointed out the need of determining for which subsets of individuals and under what conditions can legal sanctions successfully deter potential offenders. Such research will help researchers and policy makers better understand the role of deterrence, for more effective policy development related to DUI as well as other important traffic safety issues.

To Examine the Effect of China's Drunk Driving Policy, High-Quality Data Are Needed

The underestimated drink driving situation and the effects of zero tolerance laws in China.

Time-varying effect of drunk driving regulations on road traffic mortality in Guangzhou, China: an interrupted time-series analysis

Alcohol-related driving in China: Countermeasure implications of research conducted in two cities

An Analysis of Macro Effects of Drunk Driving Penalty on Motor Vehicle Traffic Accidents in China

Evaluating the Impact of Criminalizing Drunk Driving on Road-Traffic Injuries in Guangzhou, China: A Time-Series Study.

Evaluating the impact of criminalizing drunk driving on years of life lost due to road traffic deaths in one megacity, China

Evaluating the effectiveness of implementing a more severe law on prevention of road traffic injury mortality in mainland China: an interrupted time series study based on national mortality surveillance

Drunk in China? The Imperative for Effective Interventions Against Alcohol Abuse

Prevalence of Blood Alcohol in Fatal Traffic Crashes in Shanghai

Characteristics of 1226 Alcohol-Positive Drivers Involved in Nonfatal Traffic Crashes in Shanghai, China.

The Intended and Unintended Effects of Drunk Driving Policies

The role of alcohol control policies in the reversal of alcohol consumption levels and resulting attributable harms in China

Health promotion interventions and policies addressing excessive alcohol use: a systematic review of national and global evidence as a guide to health-care reform in China.

How do drunk-driving events escalate into drunk-driving crashes? An empirical analysis of Beijing from a spatiotemporal perspective

Risk perceptions and DUI decisions of drivers in different legal environments: New evidence on differential deterrence from a Chinese sample

Are Countries' Drink-Driving Policies Associated With Harms Involving Another Driver's Impairment?

Moderate Alcohol Intake and Motor Vehicle Crashes: the Conflict Between Health Advantage and At-Risk Use

Spatial relationships between alcohol outlet densities and drunk driving crashes: An empirical study of Tianjin in China

Do Tougher Drinking Policies Affect Men's Smoking Behavior - Evidence from China

Epidemiology Characteristics of Road Traffic Injury in China