Internalizing Congestion and Environmental Externalities with Green Transportation Financing Policies

Lei Zhang,Jasmy Methipara

2011-01-01

Abstract:With the declining purchasing power of the gas tax the U.S. Federal Highway Trust Fund has experienced shortfalls in revenue despite increasing transportation infrastructure maintenance and investment needs. This paper develops three green transportation financing polices based on the fixed vehicle mileage traveled (VMT) fee concept, and analyzes their impact on revenue generation, congestion management, energy/environmental sustainability, and equity at the national and state levels in the U.S. One policy is a green VMT fee that is linked to vehicle fuel economy, the second a mileage-based emissions tax correlated with vehicle greenhouse gas (GHG) and pollution emission ratings, and the third a variable VMT fee based on regional congestion levels. A demand model with vehicle miles traveled as the dependent variable is developed for the analysis. The green transportation financing options are compared against a base-case policy defined as a 10-cent/gallon increase in the Federal gas tax. To gauge policy effectiveness, we measure changes in total Federal and State revenue, VMT, fuel consumption, pollution emissions, and welfare by various demographic groups., Under all policy scenarios, total vehicle miles traveled and consumer surplus decrease with lowest-income (<$25,000/year) households showing the largest percent reduction if no compensatory schemes are employed. The distributional impact of the proposed green transportation financing policies is similar to that of the existing gas tax, with green VMT fees and emissions taxes being relatively more regressive, and nation-wide congestion pricing being relatively more progressive.