Interactive Comment on “strong Atmospheric New Particle Formation in Winter, Urban Shanghai, China” By

Shan Xiao,Mingyi Wang,L. Yao,M. Kulmala,B. Zhou,Xin Yang,Jianmin Chen,Dongfang Wang,Fu Qingyan,D. Worsnop
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/acpd-14-26655-2014
2014-01-01
Abstract:This paper reports on field measurements of new particle formation in the urban atmosphere of Shanghai. The concentrations of clusters and nanoparticles along with concentrations of potential nucleation precursors obtained during the field campaign are used to derive the nucleation and growth rates. Conclusions are made regarding the different factors that govern the nucleation and growth mechanisms. This study provides substantial data that will help to understand mechanistic details and identify the sources of secondary aerosols in China, where aerosol pollution is severe but its causes are not understood. A major deficiency of this paper is that presented data do not always substantiate the conclusions and interpretations; also, some crucial sta-tistical information is missing. These deficiencies need to be addressed before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?