Demystifying hydridic hydrogen bonds using energy decomposition analysis

Yuezhi Mao,David W. Roberts
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-c9qmw
2024-06-17
Abstract:We investigate hydridic hydrogen bonds formed by trimethylsilane (Me3SiH), where the Si atom is more electropositive than the donor hydrogen, using energy decomposition analysis methods. The primary contributions to binding, orbital interactions involved, and origins of the redshift in Si−H stretching frequency are identified and contrasted with the scenario of conventional protonic hydrogen bonds.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore and analyze the hydridic hydrogen bonds (hydridic HBs) formed by trimethylsilane (Me₃SiH), in which the Si atom is more electropositive than the donor hydrogen. Through the energy decomposition analysis (EDA) method, the authors studied the main binding contributions, orbital interactions, and the origin of the Si - H stretching frequency redshift of these hydrogen bonds, and compared them with the situation of traditional protonic hydrogen bonds (protonic HBs). Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Comparison of hydrogen bond types**: The paper compares traditional protonic hydrogen bonds (such as X - H...Y, where X is more electronegative than H, for example, X = F, O, or N) with the newly proposed hydridic hydrogen bonds (formed when the X atom is more electropositive than H). The latter was first proposed by Hobza and his colleagues, and a series of complexes involving Me₃SiH as an H - donor have been studied experimentally and theoretically. 2. **Analysis of physical mechanisms**: For hydridic hydrogen bonds, it is not clear whether their physical mechanisms (such as electrostatic interactions, orbital interactions, dispersion, etc.) are the same as those of traditional protonic hydrogen bonds. The paper analyzes in detail each component of these non - covalent interactions through the EDA method to reveal the unique properties of hydridic hydrogen bonds. 3. **Change in vibration frequency**: The paper pays special attention to the redshift phenomenon of the Si - H stretching frequency, which is observed by infrared spectroscopy in the solid state or in an Ar matrix. Through the adiabatic EDA (aEDA) method, the authors further analyze the physical origin of these redshifts, including the contributions of frozen interactions, polarization, and charge transfer. 4. **Decomposition of intermolecular forces**: The paper also explores the differences in bond length changes of different types of hydrogen bonds by decomposing the intermolecular forces along the X - H bond direction. In particular, the authors find that for hydridic hydrogen bonds, the permanent dipole - electrostatic interaction plays a dominant role in inducing a significant redshift. In summary, through detailed theoretical calculations and analyses, this paper systematically explores the properties and mechanisms of hydridic hydrogen bonds, providing important basic knowledge for understanding this new type of hydrogen bond.