Abstract:Coupled-cluster (CC) methods have been extensively used as the high-level approach in quantum electronic structure theory to predict various properties of molecules when experimental results are unavailable. It is often assumed that CC methods, if they include at least up to connected-triple-excitation quasiperturbative corrections to a full treatment of single and double excitations (in particular, CCSD(T)), and a very large basis set, are more accurate than KohnSham (KS) density functional theory (DFT). In the present work, we tested and compared the performance of standard CC and KS methods on bond energy calculations of 20 3d transition metal-containing diatomic molecules against the most reliable experimental data available, as collected in a database called 3dMLBE20. It is found that, although the CCSD(T) and higher levels CC methods have mean unsigned deviations from experiment that are smaller than most exchange-correlation functionals for metalligand bond energies of transition metals, the improvement is less than one standard deviation of the mean unsigned deviation. Furthermore, on average, almost half of the 42 exchange-correlation functionals that we tested are closer to experiment than CCSD(T) with the same extended basis set for the same molecule. The results show that, when both relativistic and corevalence correlation effects are considered, even the very high-level (expensive) CC method with single, double, triple, and perturbative quadruple cluster operators, namely, CCSDT(2)(Q), averaged over 20 bond energies, gives a mean unsigned deviation (MUD(20) = 4.7 kcal/mol when one correlates only valence, 3p, and 3s electrons of transition metals and only valence electrons of ligands, or 4.6 kcal/mol when one correlates all core electrons except for 1s shells of transition metals, S, and Cl); and that is similar to some good xc functionals (e.g., B97-1 (MUD(20) = 4.5 kcal/mol) and PW6B95 (MUD(20) = 4.9 kcal/mol)) when the same basis set is used. We found that, for both coupled cluster calculations and KS calculations, the T-1 diagnostics correlate the errors better than either the M diagnostics or the B-1 DFT-based diagnostics. The potential use of practical standard CC methods as a benchmark theory is further confounded by the finding that CC and DFT methods usually have different signs of the error. We conclude that the available experimental data do not provide a justification for using conventional single-reference CC theory calculations to validate or test xc functionals for systems involving 3d transition metals.

Vertical Ionization Energies, Generalized Kohn-Sham Orbital Energies, and the Curious Case of the Copper Oxide Anions

Ionization Potentials and Fundamental Gaps in Atomic Systems from the Ensemble-DFT Approach

Effective one-particle energies from generalized Kohn-Sham random phase approximation: A direct approach for computing and analyzing core ionization energies

Do Practical Standard Coupled Cluster Calculations Agree Better than Kohn-Sham Calculations with Currently Available Functionals When Compared to the Best Available Experimental Data for Dissociation Energies of Bonds to 3d Transition Metals?

Ab Initio Electron Propagators with an Hermitian, Intermediately Normalized Superoperator Metric Applied to Vertical Electron Affinities

Electron Binding Energies of Open-Shell Species from Diagonal Electron-Propagator Self-Energies with Unrestricted Hartree-Fock Spin-Orbitals

Energy Density Functionals From the Strong-Coupling Limit Applied to the Anions of the He Isoelectronic Series

Testing Noncollinear Spin-Flip, Collinear Spin-Flip, and Conventional Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory for Predicting Electronic Excitation Energies of Closed-Shell Atoms

Orbital Relaxation Effects on Kohn-Sham Frontier Orbital Energies in Density Functional Theory.

Orbital Energies Are Chemical Potentials in Ground-State Density Functional Theory and Excited-State $Δ$SCF Theory

Orbital Anatomy of Self-Interaction in Kohn-Sham Density Functional Theory

Reference Vertical Excitation Energies for Transition Metal Compounds

Insights into Direct Methods for Predictions of Ionization Potential and Electron Affinity in Density Functional Theory.

Theoretical study of low-lying electronic states of CuO and CuO−

How well do one-electron self-interaction-correction methods perform for systems with fractional electrons?

Local Exchange-Correlation Potentials by Density Inversion in Solids

Photoelectron spectra of early $3d$-transition metal dioxide cluster anions from $GW$ calculations

Electronic Structure and X-Ray Absorption Near Edge Spectroscopy of Copper Oxides

Quantum electrodynamic corrections for molecules: Vacuum polarisation and electron self energy in a two-component relativistic framework

Core electron binding energies of adsorbates on Cu(111) from first-principles calculations