Strength of Kitaev Interaction in Na_3Co_2SbO_6 and Na_3Ni_2BiO_6

Zefeng Chen,Binhua Zhang,Weiqin Zhu,Lianchuang Li,Boyu Liu,Junsheng Feng,Changsong Xu,Hongjun Xiang

2024-01-01

Abstract:Kitaev spin liquid is proposed to be promisingly realized in low spin-orbit coupling 3d systems, represented by Na_3Co_2SbO_6 and Na_3Ni_2BiO_6. However, the existence of Kitaev interaction is still debatable among experiments, and obtaining the strength of Kitaev interaction from first-principles calculations is also challenging. Here, we report the state-dependent anisotropy of Kitaev interaction, based on which a convenient method is developed to rapidly determine the strength of Kitaev interaction. Applying such method and density functional theory calculations, it is found that Na_3Co_2SbO_6 with 3d^7 configuration exhibits considerable ferromagnetic Kitaev interaction. Moreover, by further applying the symmetry-adapted cluster expansion method, a realistic spin model is determined for Na_3Ni_2BiO_6 with 3d^8 configuration. Such model indicates negligible small Kitaev interaction, but it predicts many properties, such as ground states and field effects, which are well consistent with measurements. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the heavy elements, Sb or Bi, located at the hollow sites of honeycomb lattice, do not contribute to emergence of Kitaev interaction through proximity, contradictory to common belief. The presently developed anisotropy method will be beneficial not only for computations but also for measurements.