Abstract:As service robots become increasingly autonomous and follow their own task-related goals, human-robot conflicts seem inevitable, especially in shared spaces. Goal conflicts can arise from simple trajectory planning to complex task prioritization. For successful human-robot goal-conflict resolution, humans and robots need to negotiate their goals and priorities. For this, the robot might be equipped with effective conflict resolution strategies to be assertive and effective but similarly accepted by the user. In this paper, conflict resolution strategies for service robots (public cleaning robot, home assistant robot) are developed by transferring psychological concepts (e.g., negotiation, cooperation) to HRI. Altogether, fifteen strategies were grouped by the expected affective outcome (positive, neutral, negative). In two online experiments, the acceptability of and compliance with these conflict resolution strategies were tested with humanoid and mechanic robots in two application contexts (public: n 1 = 61; private: n 2 = 93). To obtain a comparative value, the strategies were also applied by a human. As additional outcomes trust, fear, arousal, and valence, as well as perceived politeness of the agent were assessed. The positive/neutral strategies were found to be more acceptable and effective than negative strategies. Some negative strategies (i.e., threat, command) even led to reactance and fear. Some strategies were only positively evaluated and effective for certain agents (human or robot) or only acceptable in one of the two application contexts (i.e., approach, empathy). Influences on strategy acceptance and compliance in the public context could be found: acceptance was predicted by politeness and trust. Compliance was predicted by interpersonal power. Taken together, psychological conflict resolution strategies can be applied in HRI to enhance robot task effectiveness. If applied robot-specifically and context-sensitively they are accepted by the user. The contribution of this paper is twofold: conflict resolution strategies based on Human Factors and Social Psychology are introduced and empirically evaluated in two online studies for two application contexts. Influencing factors and requirements for the acceptance and effectiveness of robot assertiveness are discussed.

ROMEO: Towards the Design of Robot with Haptic Mediation for Remote Conflict

Exploring the Design of Robot Mediation with Bodily Contact for Remote Conflict

Promoting Mutual Adaptation in Haptic Negotiation Using Adaptive Virtual Fixture

Human-robot Negotiation of Intentions Based on Virtual Fixtures for Shared Task Execution

Multi-Modal Based Fuzzy Atmosfield in Human-Robot Interaction

What Could a Social Mediator Robot Do? Lessons from Real-World Mediation Scenarios

A Multimodal Emotional Communication Based Humans-Robots Interaction System

Design of Hesitation Gestures for Nonverbal Human-Robot Negotiation of Conflicts

Development and Testing of Psychological Conflict Resolution Strategies for Assertive Robots to Resolve Human-Robot Goal Conflict

Communication Atmosphere in Humans and Robots Interaction Based on Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process

Emotional States Based 3-D Fuzzy Atmosfield for Casual Communication Between Humans and Robots

Arm Robot: AR-Enhanced Embodied Control and Visualization for Intuitive Robot Arm Manipulation

Social Robot Mediator for Multiparty Interaction

Multimodal Integration of Emotional Signals from Voice, Body, and Context: Effects of (In)Congruence on Emotion Recognition and Attitudes Towards Robots

Step Aside! VR-Based Evaluation of Adaptive Robot Conflict Resolution Strategies for Domestic Service Robots

Hands-On Robotics: Enabling Communication Through Direct Gesture Control

Is It Me or the Robot? A Critical Evaluation of Human Affective State Recognition in a Cognitive Task

Warmth and Competence to Predict Human Preference of Robot Behavior in Physical Human-Robot Interaction

Emotional Tandem Robots: How Different Robot Behaviors Affect Human Perception While Controlling a Mobile Robot

Robots Taking Initiative in Collaborative Object Manipulation: Lessons from Physical Human-Human Interaction

A MultiModal Social Robot Toward Personalized Emotion Interaction