Essential Tremor: Treatment with Deep Brain Stimulation of the Ventral Intermediate Nucleus of the Thalamus
Meng Fan-gang,Hu Wei,Ge Yan,Ma Yu,Ge Ming,Zhang Kai,Zhang Xin,Zhang Jian-guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.0366-6999.20123224
IF: 6.133
2013-01-01
Chinese Medical Journal
Abstract:Essential tremor (ET) is one of the most common neurological degenerative disorders. Increased evidences indicated that ET is a hereditary of disease. Furthermore, this age-related, progressive disorder is thought to be associated with neuronal loss.1 It has been reported that the sensitivity and specificity of family history given by ET patients are 43.3% and 94.4%, respectively.2 Recently, deep brain stimulation (DBS) of ventral intermediate nucleus of the thalamus (Vim) has become an established treatment for ET and is widely used in the world, however, so far, no more than dozens of cases have been reported to be treated with this method in the mainland of China. Hereby, we report a Chinese patient with family essential tremor (FET), who was treated with Vim-DBS and had good outcome. Propositus (III-19), female, 64 years old, complained of right hand postural and kinetic tremor, which was initially triggered by stress and anxiety. There were 5 patients in this family (totally 49 people were surveyed), which were III-19 (propositus), II-11 (male), III-12 (female), III-25 (male) and IV-5 (male). Her mild tremor of right upper limb and head of the propositus was not noticeable until the patient was 44 years old. Her tremor of upper extremities was progressively worsening to the point that she had difficulty in her activity of daily living, for instance, due to her right hand illegible to write, she had to switch to her left hand for writing. Then, at her age of 60, this tremor spread to the left upper extremity and she lost fluency in her speech. The tremor of her head became worse and persistent when she was 62 years old. She had no symptoms of any stiffening of the body, bradykinesia, walking instability, hoarseness of voice, drink cough and so on. The patient had taken classical oral medication for her tremor, but no effect at all. Chronic bilateral Vim stimulation was chosen based on the patient's symptoms. Microelectrode recordings (FHC Inc., USA) were used to confirm the location of the Vim so as to assure the precise targeting of Vim. There are typical electrophysiological characteristics of neuronal firing within Vim and its adjacent area. Although these electrical signals did not appear only in Vim, microelectrode was used to record cells discharge which first entered into Vop. When it was in Vim, it can record the rhythm of clumps discharge consisted of limbic tremor rhythm, that is called “tremor cells”, the discharge activities of the neurons increased (Figure 1A). The discharge pattern, frequency, amplitude and background noise of the electrical signals were analyzed and the atlas of neuroanatomy was combined to confirm the upper and lower bounds of the Vim. The DBS electrode (model 3387, Medtronic Inc., Minneapolis, MN, USA) was implanted under local anesthesia. The clinical efficacy as well as side effects of stimulation was assessed during the operation procedure. The final position of the electrode was dictated by the response to macrostimulation. Then the electrode was secured to the bur-hole attachment by a locking device and a bur-hole cap using the Stimlock system. The intermittent pulse generator was connected to each DBS electrode through an extension wire and placed in the infraclavicular 1 week after the DBS implantation. A postoperative CT was performed at the day of the surgical procedure to confirm the location of electrode and exclude the adverse effects such as cerebral hemorrhage, etc.Figure 1.: Electrophysiological signals of Vim (A). The patient cannot draw and write with right hand except clicking the paper before the surgery (B). The patient can write with right hand after the surgery (C). The patient can draw with right hand after the surgery (D).The stimulator was turned on 4 weeks after the implantation of electrodes. The stimulation parameters including voltage, frequency and pulse width were modulated gradually to get optimal control of tremor without side effects. Further minor adjustments of polarities and other parameter settings were made 3 months later. Follow-up was performed every 3-6 months. The patients final settings were 2.8V (lift), 3.2V (right), 185 Hz and 90 μs, respectively. The tremor and handwriting components of the Fahn-Tolosa-Marin Tremor Rating Scale (FTMTRS) were assessed both pre- and post-operatively. The tremor was well controlled by DBS programming. Currently, the patient is able to write and draw the spiral legibly (Figure 1B-1D). The tremor score improved from 51 preoperatively to 16 postoperatively (on stimulation) and the handwriting score improved from 21 to 3. Overall, there was a 68.6% improvement in tremor and 85.7% in handwriting. There were no complications such as dysarthria, cognitive deficits and imbalance. Although associated with phenotypic variability and genetic heterogeneity, ET has been referred to as a “benign” disorder, however, the symptoms are typically progressive and potentially disabling.3 Classically, ET was defined by the Movement Disorder Society Consensus Statement on Tremor (1998) as “a bilateral, largely symmetric postural or kinetic tremor involving hands and forearms that is visible and persistent”.4 ET has been treated with DBS for long time, and the effectiveness and persistence of the tremor control effect are well confirmed. Vim is the preferred target of the DBS surgery to treat ET, reports in the literature consider that Vim-DBS can significantly improve tremor of ET. Since the initial presentation in 1987 of Vim-DBS for Parkinsonian tremor, the stereotactic community has followed Benabid, and the Vim is now the standard target for ET, although there are losses of tremor suppression due to tolerance of chronic Vim stimulation. The tremor of most patients had been significantly improved, and the daily living such as writing, drinking, eating and so on was returned to normal. In addition, the depression associated with the disease was alleviated. An average improvement in tremor of 60% to 90% is evident after thalamic DBS.3 There are 80.4% improvement in tremor and 69.7% improvement in handwriting after average follow-up period of 56.9 months. It is showed that Vim-DBS is also efficacious suitable for Chinese FET since there are 68.6% improvement in tremor and 85.7% in handwriting in this case.