Harms of Inconsistency: the Impact of User-Generated and Marketing-Generated Photos on Hotel Booking Intentions

Shan Zhang,Weifang Liu,Tingting Zhang,Wei Han,Yupeng Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2024.101249
IF: 7.608
2024-01-01
Tourism Management Perspectives
Abstract:User-generated photos (UGPs) and marketer-generated photos (MGPs) play a crucial role in reducing uncertainty during hotel booking. However, inconsistencies between these two sources of information can lead to negative consequences. This study employs the elaboration likelihood model (ELM) and Cognitive Dissonance Theory to construct two paths through which inconsistent information from UGPs and MGPs affects hotel booking intention, validated through a study with four contextual experiments involving 810 participants. Inconsistent information significantly negatively impact hotel booking intention. Perceived risk and negative emotions mediate the inconsistent effects of content and color, respectively. When price preferences are high (vs. low), the effect of inconsistent information on booking intentions is stronger. Furthermore, tourists with hedonic (vs. utilitarian) motives are less tolerant of inconsistent information. This study contributes significantly to the theoretical framework of online marketing and emphasizes the importance of considering the impact of inconsistent information on tourists in practical marketing activities.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?