Voluntary Vs. Compulsory: Examining the Consequences of Two Forms of Employee Green Behaviors

Heyuzi Shi,Lina Shangguan,Longzhu Dong,Mingze Li,Yixiang Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-05885-x
IF: 2.8
2024-01-01
Current Psychology
Abstract:Environmental sustainability has become an increasingly urgent concern for organizations. While research explores various methods for promoting employee green behaviors (EGBs), the impact of these behaviors on employees themselves remains under-investigated. This study reveals that the interpersonal impacts of voluntary and compulsory EGBs differ significantly, despite their seemingly equivalent function. Drawing upon self-determination theory and utilizing three-wave data from 231 employees, we propose and test a process model that delineates how these two EGB forms exert contrasting effects on job engagement, burnout, and fatigue through affective organizational commitment and perceptions of environmental policies hindering productivity. Our findings offer a deeper understanding of the motivational underpinnings and downstream outcomes of EGBs. They also highlight the potential for negative consequences when organizations fail to distinguish between EGBs arising from voluntary endorsement and those driven by external compliance. As organizations strive to embed sustainability within their operations, they must prioritize fostering voluntary EGBs, aligning efforts with employees' personal values, rather than resorting to coercive measures.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?