Intimate sounds of silence: its motives and consequences in romantic relationships

Netta Weinstein,Thuy-vy Nguyen,Mark Adams,C. Raymond Knee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11031-024-10078-x

IF: 4.135

2024-05-28

Motivation and Emotion

Abstract:Silence shared between partners is a rich and understudied feature of romantic relationships. Within relationships, silence may be experienced in meaningfully different ways as a function of the motivations underlying it. These internally rich experiences may affect partners differently than silence that occurs spontaneously (i.e., without intentional initiation). In four studies, we tested the motives of silence and corresponding affect and relationship quality, operationalized through psychological need satisfactions and inclusion of other into self. Studies relied on complementary methods to explore the phenomenon of silence, namely cross-sectional, daily diary, and experimental designs. Findings across studies showed that intrinsically motivated silence was felt with more positive affect and less negative affect, and that relationships were closer and more need satisfying during intrinsically motivated moments of silence. Introjected and externally motivated silences, on the other hand, were often linked to more negative affect and lower relational outcomes. Spontaneous moments of silence were not consistently linked to affect or need satisfaction.

psychology, social, experimental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the different motivations behind silence between partners and its impact on emotional and relationship quality. Through four different studies, the researchers examined the motivations for silence in romantic relationships (intrinsic motivation, introjected motivation, external motivation, and spontaneous silence) and how these motivations affect partners' emotional experiences and relationship quality.

- **Silence with intrinsic motivation**: This type of silence is associated with more positive emotional experiences and higher relationship quality. When partners choose silence out of intrinsic motivation, they usually feel more intimate and have higher relationship satisfaction.
- **Silence with introjected motivation**: This type of silence is typically accompanied by more negative emotional experiences and lower relationship quality. When partners remain silent due to self-imposed pressure, this silence may lead to negative emotions.
- **Silence with external motivation**: This type of silence is also associated with negative emotional experiences and lower relationship quality. When silence is used as a tool to amplify discord in the relationship, it similarly leads to negative outcomes.
- **Spontaneous silence**: This type of silence has no obvious motivation and usually does not consistently affect emotions or relationship quality. This kind of silence may occur naturally and thus has a smaller impact on emotional or need fulfillment.

Through cross-sectional, diary, and experimental design research methods, the authors found that different types of silence have significant impacts on partners' emotional experiences and relationship quality. Specifically, silence with intrinsic motivation can promote more positive emotions and relationship quality, while silence with introjected and external motivations brings more negative impacts. The impact of spontaneous silence is not significant. These findings help to better understand the role of silence in romantic relationships and its potential psychological mechanisms.