Abstract:The delivery performance of complex engineering projects, such as infrastructure projects, is poor and shows no sign of significant improvement. Most of these projects have been delivered by a contractor organization for a client usually a public or statutory agency. To ensure expected outcomes, the client typically employs "control instruments", such as specifying outputs, directing behaviors, selecting contractors and building relationships, to influence, or control, delivery by the contractors. The dominant literature informing the choice of control instruments is derived from organizational control theory, which primarily focuses on the exercise of control within a single organization and assumes that different types of control function independently. The persistent poor delivery performance of infrastructure projects suggests a need to revisit the recommendations of organizational control theory. While a number of papers have identified the potential of combining control instruments and the need to take into account the influence of operating in a client contractor context the mechanics and influence of specific interactions remain little understood.A case study of the delivery of the Open Pool Australian Lightwater reactor (OPAL) Nuclear Research Reactor Project in Australia, documents how the various controls employed interacted and jointly impacted on the delivery outcome. The findings start the process of further developing control theory and offer a number of practical suggestions for combining control types for practitioners.There are two main contributions to theory by this study. First, it adds support to the view that the factors influencing the principal's choice of control modes are more complex than depicted by the control theory framework. Second, it enriches the emerging balance of control literature (Cardinal et al. 2004), suggesting that it is not only the number of control modes that determines performance but also the interactions between them. Thus not only is the appropriate choice of control modes based on more than task programmability and outcome measurability, it appears that interactions between control modes also play an important role. In the case studied a combination of input, output and clan control was seen as forming an effective combination. It was also assessed to be important to avoid behavior control due to the interaction effect between behavior control and output control when employing such a grouping. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. APM and IPMA. All rights reserved.

Complements or Substitutes? Recipes of Contract Design, Contract Enforcement, and Trust for Enhanced Project Performance

Effect of contractual functions on contractors' consummate performance behaviors in construction projects

Nexus of Interorganizational Trust, Principled Negotiation, and Joint Action for Improved Cost Performance: Survey of Chinese Megaprojects

Mitigating the aftermath of relationship conflict between the owners and contractors: a contract enforcement approach

Study on the Impact of Trust and Contract Governance on Project Management Performance in the Whole Process Consulting Project—Based on the SEM and fsQCA Methods

Conjunct Roles of Client and Vendor Control in Offshore-Outsourced Project Performance

Joint Contract–Function Effects on BIM-Enabled EPC Project Performance

What Makes Logistics Integration More Effective? Governance from Contractual and Relational Perspectives

External drivers of inter-organizational collaboration in megaproject: a perspective based on project governance

Investigating the impact of multiple governance mechanisms on new infrastructure projects performance: evidence from China

How to foster contractors' cooperative behavior in the Chinese construction industry: Direct and interaction effects of power and contract

UNDERSTANDING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN TASK CONFLICT AND CONSTRUCTION PROJECT PERFORMANCE: UNCERTAINTY MANAGEMENT PERSPECTIVE

Strategic governance dynamics in manufacturing firms: navigating operational performance through contractual and relational mechanisms in the face of product complexity

Complements or Substitutes? Configurational Effects of Entrepreneurial Activities and Institutional Frameworks on Social Well-Being

How optimal trust–dependence nexus facilitates relational behavior in contractor–subcontractor collaboration: a configurational analysis

Relationships among Contracting Parties and Their Effects on Outcomes of Public Construction Projects in China

The impact of relational governance on the adaptability of international contractors: a comparative study between China and Korea

Revisiting the Interplay of Trust and Contracts: the Roles of Technological Turbulence and Dependence Disadvantage

Delivering Complex Engineering Projects: Reexamining Organizational Control Theory

Coordinating Project Outsourcing Through Bilateral Contract Negotiations

Do control mechanisms always promote collaborative performance: the role of formal institutions and business ties