Optimum Model-Based Design of Diagnostics Experiments (DOE) with Hybrid Pulse Power Characterization (HPPC) for Lithium-Ion Batteries

Debbie Zhuang,Jinwook Rhyu,Martin Bazant,Richard Braatz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-f8rq5
2024-04-15
Abstract:Diagnostics of lithium-ion batteries are frequently performed in battery management systems for optimized operation of lithium-ion batteries or for second-life usage. However, attempting to extract dominant degradation information requires long rest times between diagnostic pulses, which compete with the need for efficient diagnostics. Here, we design a set of efficient optimal hybrid pulse power characterization (HPPC) diagnostics using model-based design of experiment (DOE) methods, applying knowledge of degradation effects on pulse kinetics and cell properties. We validate that these protocols are effective through minimization of uncertainty, and robust with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulations. Contrary to traditional HPPC diagnostics which use fixed pulse magnitudes at uniformly distributed state of charges (SOC), we find that well-designed HPPC protocols using our framework outperform traditional protocols in terms of minimizing both parametric uncertainties and diagnostic time. Trade-offs between minimizing parametric uncertainty and total diagnostic time can be made based on different diagnostics needs.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to design an efficient diagnostic experimental method for lithium-ion batteries to optimize the Hybrid Pulse Power Characterization (HPPC) test. Specifically, the paper addresses the following key issues: 1. **Improving Diagnostic Efficiency**: Traditional HPPC diagnostic methods require long rest periods between diagnostic pulses, leading to prolonged diagnostic times. The paper designs an efficient HPPC diagnostic protocol using a model-based Design of Experiments (DOE) method, reducing diagnostic time while maintaining the accuracy of parameter estimation. 2. **Reducing Parameter Uncertainty**: Identifying battery degradation mechanisms is often accompanied by uncertainty in parameter estimation. By optimizing pulse settings, the paper minimizes parameter estimation uncertainty, thereby improving diagnostic accuracy. 3. **Balancing Diagnostic Time and Accuracy**: The paper explores how to balance minimizing parameter uncertainty and total diagnostic time under different diagnostic requirements. By constructing a Pareto front, it demonstrates the trade-off relationship between time and accuracy for different diagnostic protocols. 4. **Validating Robustness**: The paper uses the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulation method to evaluate the robustness of the designed HPPC protocol under different degradation states, ensuring the effectiveness and reliability of the diagnostic method. ### Main Contributions - **Efficient Diagnostic Protocol Design**: An optimized HPPC diagnostic protocol is designed through a model-driven DOE method, significantly reducing diagnostic time. - **Minimization of Parameter Uncertainty**: By optimizing pulse settings, parameter estimation uncertainty is minimized, improving diagnostic accuracy. - **Multi-Objective Optimization**: By constructing a Pareto front, the trade-off relationship between diagnostic time and accuracy is demonstrated, providing guidance for practical applications. - **Robustness Validation**: The robustness of the designed HPPC protocol under different degradation states is validated using the MCMC method. ### Application Background With the widespread application of renewable energy sources such as solar and wind energy, energy storage technology has become increasingly important. As the primary energy storage device, the performance and lifespan monitoring and management of lithium-ion batteries are crucial. Battery Management Systems (BMS) need to monitor the degradation state of batteries in real-time to optimize battery operation and extend their lifespan. Additionally, the secondary use and recycling of lithium-ion batteries also require accurate degradation information. Therefore, efficient battery diagnostic methods are of great significance for these application scenarios.