Azoniafluorenones: A New Family of Two-electron Storage Electrolytes for Sustainable Near-Neutral pH Aqueous Organic Flow Battery

Petri Pihko,Maxime Artault,Pekka Peljo,Gabriel Gonzalez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-hvwc6

2024-04-10

Abstract:Fluorenones are suitable candidate for negolytes in flow batteries, as they demonstrate ability to store 2 electrons, and can achieve reversibility, solubility, and stability with appropriate molecular design. However, limitations persist such as the use of alkaline media, high redox potentials, and a limited scope for optimization. Herein, we report azoniafluorenones as a novel class of negolytes. They can be readily accessed in a highly modular fashion from inexpensive commercially available materials (e.g., boronic acids). Variations in the substitution patterns reveals the 3-substituted N-alkylated AZON3, which demonstrates excellent solubility at neutral pH (1.64 M) with two low reversible redox potentials (–0.31 V and –0.58 V vs Ag/AgCl). AZON3 exhibits high stability when evaluated at high concentration in a neutral supporting electrolyte (1 M in 3 M KCl), paired with BTMAP-Fc on the positive side. Capacity retentions of 99.95% and 99.91% per cycle (99.35% and 99.21% per day) are achieved when cycling with 1 and 2 electrons, respectively, coupled with high volumetric capacity of 46.4 Ah L-1 (87% of capacity utilization).

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the problem of developing an efficient and stable two-electron storage electrolyte under neutral pH conditions for sustainable aqueous organic flow batteries (AOFBs). Specifically, the authors aim to overcome the limitations of existing fluorenone-based anode materials in terms of energy density, reversibility, and stability by designing and synthesizing new compounds—Azoniafluorenones (AZONs).

### Background and Issues
1. **Energy Storage Demand**: With the widespread adoption of renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power, there is an urgent need to develop economical, scalable, and safe energy storage technologies to support the grid integration of these intermittent energy sources.
2. **Advantages of Flow Batteries**: Flow batteries (FBs) are a potential solution due to their safety, cost-effectiveness, long-term durability, and adjustable energy/power levels.
3. **Limitations of Existing Technologies**:
- **Transition Metal-Based Electrolytes**: For example, vanadium-based flow batteries (VFBs) are close to commercialization, but their high cost and toxicity limit widespread application.
- **Alkaline and Acidic Environments**: Existing aqueous organic flow batteries (AOFBs) typically operate in alkaline or acidic environments, which increases corrosion risk and material costs.
- **Energy Density**: The energy density of AOFBs is limited by the solubility of organic compounds in water and the number of electrons each redox species can transfer/store.
- **Limitations of Existing Fluorenone-Based Anode Materials**: For instance, (OTDFL)Cl₂, while having good reversibility and solvation ability, faces issues with high reduction potential and stability under neutral pH conditions.

### Solution
1. **Design and Synthesis of Novel Azoniafluorenones (AZONs)**:
- Introducing a pyridinium ring to enhance solvation ability and adjust reduction potential.
- Optimizing molecular structure to improve solubility, stability, and reversibility under neutral pH conditions.
2. **Experimental Validation**:
- Evaluating the electrochemical performance and stability of AZONs through cyclic voltammetry (CV) and lab-scale flow battery tests.
- Specifically, 3-substituted AZON3 exhibits excellent solvation ability (1.64 M), low reversible reduction potentials (-0.31 V and -0.58 V vs Ag/AgCl), and high stability.
3. **Mechanism Study**:
- Investigating the electrochemical behavior of AZON3 under different pH conditions to reveal the mechanism of two-electron storage through proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) under neutral pH conditions.

### Key Findings
- **High Solvation Ability**: AZON3 has a solvation ability of up to 1.64 M in 1 M KCl.
- **Low Reduction Potentials**: In 1 M KCl, the two reduction potentials of AZON3 are -0.31 V and -0.58 V vs Ag/AgCl.
- **High Stability**: In 1 M KCl, AZON3 as an anode material shows capacity retention rates of 99.95% and 99.91% per cycle (99.35% and 99.21% per day).
- **High Energy Density**: The average cell voltage of the battery is 0.63 V, with a volumetric capacity of 46.4 Ah L⁻¹ (87% capacity utilization).

In summary, the paper successfully addresses the issues of energy density, reversibility, and stability of existing fluorenone-based anode materials under neutral pH conditions by designing and synthesizing novel Azoniafluorenones (AZONs), providing a new direction for the development of efficient and stable aqueous organic flow batteries.