Abstract:The 2015 Paris Agreement is falling short of its aspirations, as signatory countries are struggling to implement the policies required to meet the targets. The global scenario framework formed by the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs) and the Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) places little emphasis on the dynamics of climate policy implementation. Social science approaches to understanding these dynamics are not well-integrated into climate scenario research. We apply an implementation research approach to analyse the transition to clean energy in the US and China, as well as two examples from Europe – Germany and Spain – which have shown markedly diverging implementation trajectories. We propose four implementation scenarios (ISs) for clean energy worldwide which relate to different configurations of actors in the policy system. These are: (1) Civil Society Takes Control (IS1) – where ideologically opposed governments are marginalised by citizens and forward-thinking investors; (2) Strong-arm Transition (IS2) – where a single party state drives the transition without the involvement of civil society; (3) Systemic Limits (IS3) – which highlights the need to focus on the whole energy system, not just renewables; and (4) Renewable Austerity (IS4) – where an economic downturn offers powerful anti-transition actors the opportunity to advocate removal of support for climate mitigation, as they did after the 2007–2008 financial crisis. This scenario could be repeated as countries seek to recover from the Covid-19 pandemic. Our study offers a framework for structured analysis of real-world constraints faced by implementing actors, which we argue is urgently needed to help national and international policy makers achieve climate goals. Key policy insights The world is struggling to implement the Paris Agreement, partly because the complex dynamics of climate policy implementation are poorly understood.Social science approaches to understanding these dynamics are not well-integrated into climate scenario research.Implementation research focussing on the actors and context provides a useful framework for analysis of implementation efforts from major global carbon emitters.The approach offers new and distinctive scenario narratives that go beyond Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) and Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs).These new scenarios can help policy makers evaluate likely outcomes of climate policy implementation based on information about actors and context.

Scenario-based Policy Representative Exploration: A Novel Approach to Analyzing Policy Portfolios and Its Application to Low-Carbon Energy Diffusion

Simulating Policy Interventions in the Interfirm Diffusion of Low-Carbon Technologies: an Agent-Based Evolutionary Game Model

MId-Term Simulation Analysis of the Policy Interaction Between Emission Regulation and RES Promotion

A Dynamical System Model to Analyze the Low Carbon Transition in Energy-Economic System

Synergistic effects of carbon cap-and-trade and renewable portfolio standards on renewable energy diffusion

Evaluating and optimizing environmental tax, carbon trading scheme and renewable portfolio standard in China: An E-DSGE model

A Novel $δ$-SBM-OPA Approach for Policy-Driven Analysis of Carbon Emission Efficiency under Uncertainty in the Chinese Industrial Sector

A dual-core system dynamics approach for carbon emission spillover effects analysis and cross-regional policy simulation

Synergizing policies for carbon reduction, energy transition and pollution control: Evidence from Chinese power generation industry

Diffusion of new energy vehicles under incentive policies of China: Moderating role of market characteristic

Dynamics of Energy Technology Diffusion under Uncertainty

Transition towards a hybrid energy system: Combined effects of renewable portfolio standards and carbon emission trading

Hierarchical multi-objective design of regional integrated energy system under heterogeneous low-carbon policies

Policy Tool Interactions and the Adoption of State Renewable Portfolio Standards

System dynamics-based effectiveness and sustainability analysis of renewable energy generation policy in China

ANALYSIS OF THE SYNERGISTIC EFFECT OF CARBON TAXES AND CLEAN ENERGY SUBSIDIES: AN ENTERPRISE-HETEROGENEITY E-DSGE MODEL APPROACH

Public response to heterogeneous environmental policies: scenario-based experiments from interest appeal, implementation costs, and commitment mechanism

Beyond shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs) and representative concentration pathways (RCPs): climate policy implementation scenarios for Europe, the US and China

Stackelberg game‐theoretic model for low carbon energy market scheduling

Can a Policy Mix Achieve a Collaborative Effect? Exploring the Nested Implementation Process of Urban Carbon Emission Reduction Policies

Exploring the Dynamics of Low-Carbon Technology Diffusion among Enterprises: an Evolutionary Game Model on a Two-Level Heterogeneous Social Network