Choice of Channel Governance Strategies Based on Channel Organization Formats: A New Perspective of Interfirm Governance in Marketing Channels
Zhuang Guijun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2012.06.009
2012-01-01
Abstract:Mistaking the transactional governance as a one-dimensional and continual variable from the hierarchy mechanism to the market mechanism,the previous studies have neither discussed the real meaning and ingredients of "the mediate governance forms" or "hybrid governance forms" which are adopted in marketing channels nor proposed the formalized strategies of channel governance that firms can follow.This has,on the one hand,largely impeded the further exploration of channel governance and limited the discussion on the issue to the advantages and/or disadvantages of the formal mechanism verses informal or relational mechanism and the supplementary or substitution relationship between them,and on the other hand,made the theory difficult to apply in practice.Based on the arguments about the three dimensions(namely ownership,authority,and incentives) of transactional governance,this paper elaborates on the relationship between channel organization formats and channel governance strategies,and proposes a model for firms to choose channel governance strategies based on channel organization formats.The major points of the article are: firstly,the corporate,contractual,administrate and relational vertical marketing system used by firms in practice as channel organization formats are in fact the different channel governance strategies,and they can be defined by the three dimensions of transactional governance.Secondly,a firm may therefore design and choose its channel governance strategies based on the channel organization formats by using the model proposed in the paper as guidance.Thirdly,the factors influencing a firm to design and choose its channel governance strategies(or equally,channel organization formats) include its specific transactional investments,the environment uncertainty,its desire for channel control,its size and capability,the characteristics of its product and industry,its channel goals and tasks,the channel structure,and the factors of its channel partner,and the consequences of a firm’s channel governance strategy include the firm’s behaviors of channel control,infirm relationship quality,channel satisfaction,and the firm’s performance and efficiency.The paper ends with a discussion on the importance of our arguments in the theory development and practice of marketing channel governance and management.