Complex interplay of science reasoning and vaccine hesitancy among parents in Shanghai, China

Felicia Zhang,Jia Ren,Colin Garon,Zhuoying Huang,John Kubale,Abram L. Wagner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-024-17990-4

IF: 4.5

2024-02-23

BMC Public Health

Abstract:Abstract The psychosocial underpinnings of vaccine hesitancy are complex. Research is needed to pinpoint the exact reasons why people hesitate to vaccinate themselves or their children against vaccine-preventable diseases. One possible reason are concerns that arise from a misunderstanding of vaccine science. We examined the impact of scientific reasoning on vaccine hesitancy and human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination intent through a cross-sectional study of parents of vaccine-eligible children ( N = 399) at immunization clinics in Shanghai, China. We assessed the relationship between science reasoning and both vaccine hesitancy and HPV vaccine acceptance using general additive models. We found a significant association between scientific reasoning and education level, with those with less than a high school education having a significantly lower scientific reasoning that those with a college education (ß = -1.31, p-value = 0.002). However, there was little evidence of a relationship between scientific reasoning and vaccine hesitancy. Scientific reasoning therefore appears not to exert primary influence on the formation of vaccine attitudes among the respondents surveyed. We suggest that research on vaccine hesitancy continues working to identify the styles of reasoning parents engage in when determining whether or not to vaccinate their children. This research could inform the development and implementation of tailored vaccination campaigns.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the relationship between scientific reasoning ability, vaccine hesitancy and the willingness to accept the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine. Specifically, the research objectives include:

1. **Research background and problem statement**:
- Vaccine hesitancy refers to people's still being skeptical or refusing to be vaccinated despite the availability of vaccines. This phenomenon is widespread in different regions and populations and may lead to the outbreak of vaccine - preventable diseases.
- Especially for the HPV vaccine, it is theoretically highly cost - effective even in low - and middle - income countries, but its promotion is affected by vaccine hesitancy.

2. **Research purposes**:
- **Understanding the distribution of scientific reasoning ability**: By investigating the scientific reasoning ability of Shanghai parents, understand the impact of different demographic characteristics (such as education level, income, living status, etc.) on scientific reasoning ability.
- **Analyzing the relationship between scientific reasoning and vaccine hesitancy**: Evaluate whether scientific reasoning ability is related to vaccine hesitancy, especially by using the Parent Attitudes about Childhood Vaccines (PACV) scale to measure the degree of vaccine hesitancy.
- **Evaluating the impact of scientific reasoning on the willingness to accept the HPV vaccine**: Study the impact of scientific reasoning ability and vaccine hesitancy on parents' willingness to vaccinate their 12 - year - old children with the HPV vaccine.

3. **Research methods**:
- **Sample selection**: The research subjects are parents with school - age children in Shanghai immunization clinics, with a total of 399 participants.
- **Measurement tools**: Use the Scientific Reasoning Scale (SRS) to assess scientific reasoning ability, use the PACV scale to assess vaccine hesitancy, and collect data on the willingness to accept the HPV vaccine through questionnaires.
- **Statistical analysis**: Use linear regression models and General Additive Models (GAMs) for data analysis.

4. **Expected contributions**:
- Through this research, we can better understand the role of scientific reasoning ability in vaccine hesitancy, thereby providing a basis for formulating more targeted vaccine promotion and education strategies.
- Especially in middle - and high - income countries like China, the research results are helpful for optimizing the promotion strategy of the HPV vaccine and improving the public's trust and acceptance of vaccines.

In summary, this paper attempts to reveal the complex relationship between scientific reasoning ability, vaccine hesitancy and the willingness to accept the HPV vaccine through empirical research, in order to provide valuable reference information for public health policy makers.