Assessing Heavy Metal Contamination in Singed Goat Meat: Insights from Hot Water and Scrap Car Tire Singeing on Public Health and Environmental Safety

Mathew Gideon,Usman Muazu,Abakeyah James Mamman ,Emmanuel Kambai Duniya
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-xmp0d
2024-04-04
Abstract:The study investigated the presence of heavy metals, including cadmium, copper, lead, zinc, and iron, drinking water, hot water singed goat meat (AS) and scrap car tire singed goat meat (AU) in Kakuri abattoir of Kaduna Metropolis. Cadmium was not detected in all the samples tested. Copper concentrations were 0.016 mg/kg in AS and 0.013 mg/kg in AU, indicating a 23% decrease. Lead was not detected in AS and 0.011 mg/kg in AU, with a substantial percentage increase. Zinc concentrations were 0.110 mg/kg in AS and 0.969 mg/kg in AU, displaying a significant 780.91% increase. Iron concentrations were 0.816 mg/kg in AS and 2.343 mg/kg in AU, showing a notable 187.25% increase. Although all concentrations remained below under the ECR RML= European Commission Regulation (2006) Recommended maximum limit (RML) for meat samples and WHO 2011 for Drinking Water, AU exceeded the limit for iron by 0.343 mg/kg. The elemental composition within car tires follows a distinct order: Zinc (Zn) > Copper (Cu) > Lead (Pb) > Cadmium (Cd), which is consistent with the concentration of these metals in the study. This research underscores the importance of employing appropriate techniques to balance regulatory compliance and industrial viability, ensuring the sustainable utilization of hides and skins while minimizing environmental and health risks.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the evaluation of the impact of using hot water and waste car tire singeing on goat meat in terms of heavy metal contamination, as well as the potential risks of this treatment method to public health and environmental safety. Specifically, the study focuses on the levels of heavy metals such as cadmium, copper, lead, zinc, and iron in singed goat meat from the Kakuri abattoir in the Kaduna metropolitan area, and explores the sources of these heavy metals and their potential threats to human health. ### Main Issues: 1. **Heavy Metal Contamination**: The study aims to detect and compare the levels of heavy metals, including cadmium, copper, lead, zinc, and iron, in goat meat treated with hot water and waste car tire singeing. 2. **Public Health Risk**: Assess whether the concentrations of these heavy metals exceed the maximum limits recommended by the European Commission Regulations (ECR) and the World Health Organization (WHO), thereby determining the potential risk to consumer health. 3. **Environmental Safety**: Explore the potential impact of using waste car tires as singeing material on the environment, particularly whether the heavy metals contained in the tires are transferred to the goat meat during the singeing process. ### Research Background: - **Traditional Practice**: In Nigeria and other parts of Africa, singeing animal hides to remove hair is a common practice, typically using wood or agricultural waste as fuel. - **Alternative Materials**: Due to environmental policies restricting the use of wood and rising fuel prices, there is an increasing use of plastics, waste car tires, and charcoal as alternative fuels. - **Health Risks**: These alternative materials may release toxic organic compounds and heavy metals during combustion, posing a threat to consumer health. ### Research Objectives: - **Compare Different Treatment Methods**: Evaluate the impact of different treatment methods on food safety by comparing the levels of heavy metals in goat meat treated with hot water and waste car tire singeing. - **Provide Recommendations**: Based on the research results, propose recommendations to improve singeing treatment methods to reduce heavy metal contamination, ensuring consumer health and environmental protection. ### Conclusion: - **Heavy Metal Detection Results**: The study found that the levels of copper, lead, zinc, and iron in goat meat treated with waste car tire singeing significantly increased, with zinc and iron levels increasing by 780.91% and 187.25%, respectively. - **Health Risk Assessment**: Although all detected heavy metal concentrations did not exceed the maximum limits recommended by the European Commission Regulations and the World Health Organization, the significant changes in concentration still warrant attention. - **Recommendations**: It is recommended to use hot water for singeing treatment when necessary to further reduce heavy metal content, while balancing economic and environmental considerations to ensure the sustainable development of the leather industry. Through this study, the authors hope to raise awareness among the public and related industries about the issue of heavy metal contamination during the singeing process and to promote the adoption of safer and more environmentally friendly treatment methods.