Abstract:In efforts to improve methane source characterisation, networks of cheap high-frequency in situ sensors are required, with parts-per-million-level methane mole fraction ([CH4]) precision. Low-cost semiconductor-based metal oxide sensors, such as the Figaro Taguchi Gas Sensor (TGS) 2611-E00, may satisfy this requirement. The resistance of these sensors decreases in response to the exposure of reducing gases, such as methane. In this study, we set out to characterise the Figaro TGS 2611-E00 in an effort to eventually yield [CH4] when deployed in the field. We found that different gas sources containing the same ambient 2 ppm [CH4] level yielded different resistance responses. For example, synthetically generated air containing 2 ppm [CH4] produced a lower sensor resistance than 2 ppm [CH4] found in natural ambient air due to possible interference from supplementary reducing gas species in ambient air, though the specific cause of this phenomenon is not clear. TGS 2611-E00 carbon monoxide response is small and incapable of causing this effect. For this reason, ambient laboratory air was selected as a testing gas standard to naturally incorporate such background effects into a reference resistance. Figaro TGS 2611-E00 resistance is sensitive to temperature and water vapour mole fraction ([H2O]). Therefore, a reference resistance using this ambient air gas standard was characterised for five sensors (each inside its own field logging enclosure) using a large environmental chamber, where logger enclosure temperature ranged between 8 and 38 ∘C and [H2O] ranged between 0.4 % and 1.9 %. [H2O] dominated resistance variability in the standard gas. A linear [H2O] and temperature model fit was derived, resulting in a root mean squared error (RMSE) between measured and modelled resistance in standard gas of between ±0.4 and ±1.0 kΩ for the five sensors, corresponding to a fractional resistance uncertainty of less than ±3 % at 25 ∘C and 1 % [H2O]. The TGS 2611-E00 loggers were deployed at a landfill site for 242 d before and 96 d after sensor testing. Yet the standard (i.e. ambient air) reference resistance model fit based on temperature and [H2O] could not replicate resistance measurements made in the field, where [CH4] was mostly expected to be close to the ambient background, with minor enhancements. This field disparity may have been due to variability in sensor cooling dynamics, a difference in ambient air composition during environmental chamber testing compared to the field or variability in natural sensor response, either spontaneously or environmentally driven. Despite difficulties in replicating a standard reference resistance in the field, we devised an excellent methane characterisation model up to 1000 ppm [CH4] by using the ratio between measured resistance with [CH4] enhancement and its corresponding reference resistance in standard gas. A bespoke power-type fit between resistance ratio and [CH4] resulted in an RMSE between the modelled and measured resistance ratio of no more than ±1 % Ω Ω−1 for the five sensors. This fit and its corresponding fit parameters were then inverted and the original resistance ratio values were used to derive [CH4], yielding an inverted model [CH4] RMSE of less than ±1 ppm, where [CH4] was limited to 28 ppm. Our methane response model allows other reducing gases to be included if necessary by characterising additional model coefficients. Our model shows that a 1 ppm [CH4] enhancement above the ambient background results in a resistance drop of between 1.4 % and 2.0 % for the five tested sensors. With future improvements in deriving a standard reference resistance, the TGS 2611-E00 offers great potential in measuring [CH4] with parts-per-million-level precision.

Determining Methane Mole Fraction at a Landfill Site Using the Figaro Taguchi Gas Sensor 2611-C00 and Wind Direction Measurements

Characterising the Methane Gas and Environmental Response of the Figaro Taguchi Gas Sensor (TGS) 2611-E00

Emission Determination by Three Remote Sensing Methods in Two Release Trials

Using metal oxide gas sensors for the estimate of methane controlled releases: reconstruction of the methane mole fraction time-series and quantification of the release rates and locations

Using metal oxide gas sensors to estimate the emission rates and locations of methane leaks in an industrial site: assessment with controlled methane releases

Detection and long-term quantification of methane emissions from an active landfill

The Potential of Low-Cost Tin-Oxide Sensors Combined with Machine Learning for Estimating Atmospheric CH4 Variations Around Background Concentration

Mobile Measurements of Atmospheric Methane at Eight Large Landfills: An Assessment of Temporal and Spatial Variability

Using Ground- and Drone-Based Surface Emission Monitoring (SEM) Data to Locate and Infer Landfill Methane Emissions

Investigation of Methane Fluxes from Temporary Cover of Xi’an Jiangcungou Landfill, China

Reconstruction of High-Frequency Methane Atmospheric Concentration Peaks from Measurements Using Metal Oxide Low-Cost Sensors

Short-term landfill methane emissions dependency on wind

A methodology to characterize a sanitary landfill combining, through a numerical approach, a geoelectrical survey with methane point-source concentrations

Determination of emission factors from a landfill through an inverse methodology: Experimental determination of ambient air concentrations and use of numerical modelling

Landfill Emissions of Methane Inferred from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle and Mobile Ground Measurements

In-Situ Testing of Methane Emissions from Landfills Using Laser Absorption Spectroscopy

Determination of gas composition in a biogas plant using a Raman-based sensor system

Calibration of a Low-Cost Methane Sensor Using Machine Learning

Detection of Methane Leaks via a Drone-Based System for Sustainable Landfills and Oil and Gas Facilities: Effect of Different Variables on the Background-Noise Measurement

Design and evaluation of a low-cost sensor node for near-background methane measurement

A Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy-Based Methane Flux Sensor for Quantification of Venting Sources at Oil and Gas Sites