Abstract:Mounting experimental evidence supports the existence of a liquid-liquid transition (LLT) in high-pressure supercooled water. However, fast crystallization of supercooled water has impeded identification of the LLT line TLL(p) in experiments. While the most accurate all-atom (AA) water models display a LLT, their computational cost limits investigations of its interplay with ice formation. Coarse-grained (CG) models provide over 100-fold computational efficiency gain over AA models, enabling the study of water crystallization, but have not yet shown to have a LLT. Here we demonstrate that the CG machine-learned water model ML-BOP has a LLT that ends in a critical point at pc = 170±10 MPa and Tc = 181±3 K. The TLL(p) of ML-BOP is almost identical to the one of TIP4P/2005, adding to the similarity in the equation of state of liquid water in both models. Cooling simulations reveal that ice crystallization is fastest at the liquid-liquid transition and its supercritical continuation of maximum heat capacity, supporting a mechanistic relationship between the structural transformation of water to a low-density liquid and ice formation. We find no signature of liquid-liquid criticality in the ice crystallization temperatures. ML-BOP repli-cates the competition between formation of low-density liquid (LDL) and ice observed in ultrafast experiments of decompres-sion of the high-density liquid (HDL) into the region of stability of LDL. The simulations reveal that crystallization occurs prior to the coarsening of the HDL and LDL domains, obscuring the distinction between the highly metastable first order LLT and pronounced structural fluctuations along its supercritical continuation.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between Liquid-Liquid Transition (LLT) and ice crystallization in a coarse-grained water model obtained through machine learning (ML-BOP). Specifically, the study addresses the following key issues: 1. **Confirmed that the ML-BOP model can successfully simulate liquid-liquid transition**: Through simulations, it was found that this model can not only reproduce the liquid-liquid transition but also locate its critical point around 170±10 MPa and 181±3 K. This result is very close to those obtained from other advanced atomic models like TIP4P/2005. 2. **Revealed the competitive relationship between liquid-liquid transition and ice crystallization**: The study shows that the rate of water crystallization is fastest when the liquid-liquid transition occurs. This means that avoiding crystallization while studying liquid-liquid transition is very difficult, as both occur under the same conditions. 3. **Simulated the decompression process of high-density liquid water (HDL) under ultrafast experimental conditions**: By rapidly decompressing HDL to reach the stable region of low-density liquid water (LDL), the study simulated this process and observed the transition from HDL to LDL and ice. These simulation results are consistent with experimental observations, demonstrating the model's effectiveness. 4. **Determined the liquid-liquid transition line (TLL(p))**: The study determined the position of the liquid-liquid transition line through various methods and found that the existence of this transition line can explain why it is difficult to directly observe the liquid-liquid transition in experiments. 5. **Analyzed the relationship between ice crystallization temperature and liquid-liquid transition**: Although no characteristics of liquid-liquid criticality were observed at the ice crystallization temperature, the study found a mechanical relationship between liquid-liquid transition and ice crystallization. The transition of water structure to low-density liquid promotes ice formation. In summary, this paper uses theoretical simulation methods to deeply study the phenomenon of liquid-liquid transition and reveals the intrinsic connection between this phenomenon and ice crystallization, providing a new perspective for understanding the anomalous properties of water.

Liquid-Liquid Transition and Ice Crystallization in a Machine-Learned Coarse grained Water Model

The Putative Liquid-Liquid Transition is a Liquid-Solid Transition in Atomistic Models of Water

Liquid-liquid phase transitions in supercooled water studied by computer simulations of various water models

Homogeneous nucleation of phase transformations in supercooled water

Reversible structural transformations in supercooled water from 135 to 245 K

Two-state thermodynamics and the possibility of a liquid-liquid phase transition in supercooled TIP4P/2005 water

Is There A Liquid-Liquid Transition in Confined Water?

Structural transformation in supercooled water controls the crystallization rate of ice

Liquid-liquid transition in supercooled aqueous solution involving a low-temperature phase similar to low-density amorphous water

Experimental observation of the liquid-liquid transition in bulk supercooled water under pressure

Two state model for the ML-BOP potential

Is there a liquid-liquid phase transition in supercooled water ?

Supercritical density fluctuations and structural heterogeneity in supercooled water-glycerol microdroplets

Machine Learning-Generated TIP4P-BGWT Model for Liquid and Supercooled Water

Deeply-cooled Water under Strong Confinement: Neutron Scattering Investigations and the Liquid-Liquid Critical Point Hypothesis.

Phase behavior of metastable water from large-scale simulations of a quantitative accurate model: The liquid-liquid critical point

Phase behavior of metastable water from large-scale simulations of a quantitatively accurate model near ambient conditions: The liquid-liquid critical point

Liquid-Liquid Critical Point in 3D Many-Body Water Model

Behavior of Supercooled Aqueous Solutions Stemming from Hidden Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water

Pinpointing the Location of the Elusive Liquid-Liquid Critical Point in Water

Liquid-to-liquid Phase Transition Underlying the Structural Crossover in a Supercooled Metallic Liquid