Assessment of Risk and Processing Effects on Banned Pesticide Residue Levels in Nigerian Staple Foods

Daniel Ojochenemi Apeh,Joseph Eniola Olajide,Keleojo Anthony Enwuchola
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-12pzc
2024-03-12
Abstract:The use of pesticides has overwhelming advantage to food security but not so much to the environmentalists and toxicologists. Governments of nations or regions have over the years restricted or banned the use of certain pesticides. This work examined the incidence, dietary exposure and risk characterization of some Nigerian-banned organochlorine and organophosphate pesticides in rice, cassava, maize and beans marketed in Kogi state, Nigeria. The extraction of pesticide residues was performed using the Quick, Effective, Cheap, Easy, Rugged and Safe (QuEChERS) technique, and gas chromatography tandem mass spectrometry was used for quantification of the pesticide residues in the samples. The residues detected in order of decreasing incidence were methoxychlor, α-chlordane, γ-chlordane, endosulfan II, dieldrin, aldrin, p,p'-DDE, Δ-BHC (hexachlorobenzene), endrin aldehyde, p,p'-DDD, lindane, p,p'-DDT, and endosulfan sulfate. No assayed organophosphate residue was detected. Methoxychlor and α-chlordane had the highest incidences of 46.88% and 31.25% respectively, while lindane, p,p'-DDT and endosulfan sulfate had the lowest incidence (3.13% in each case). The processing steps applied including cold water washing, warm water washing, soaking and fermentation had various effects on the level of residues ranging from -149% to 100% reduction in level of pesticide, and are recommended. Risk characterization by percentage tolerable daily intake estimation showed that aldrin and dieldrin were detected at concentrations that far exceeds the safety threshold, the hazard index also revealed that Δ-BHC (hexachlorobenzene), lindane, aldrin, dieldrin and methoxychlor were present in staples at levels with potentials to induce chronic toxicity. None detection, low incidence, low concentrations and low hazard index and risk posed by most pesticides in this study is indicative that the ban on these pesticides has been impactful in reducing their use within Nigeria and consequently in averting health challenges associated with their use. Finding them at any level should alert the regulatory agencies to further strategize towards risk mitigation and elimination.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly include: 1. **Evaluating the residue levels and risks of banned pesticides in Nigeria's staple foods**: - The paper aims to study the residue situations of some organochlorine and organophosphorus pesticides banned by the Nigerian government in rice, cassava, maize and beans, as well as the risks of these residues to consumers' health. 2. **Analyzing the influence of food processing steps on pesticide residues**: - Through different food processing methods (such as cold - water rinsing, warm - water rinsing, soaking and fermentation), evaluate the effectiveness of these methods in reducing pesticide residues. 3. **Risk characterization analysis**: - By estimating the estimated daily intake (EDI), the percentage of tolerable daily intake (%TDI) and the hazard index (HI), assess the potential health risks of the detected pesticide residues to consumers. ### Specific problem decomposition - **Residue level assessment**: - Use the QuEChERS technique to extract pesticide residues and conduct quantitative analysis by gas chromatography - tandem mass spectrometry (GC - MS/MS). - The detected pesticide residues in descending order of occurrence frequency are: methoxychlor, α - chlordane, γ - chlordane, dieldrin, heptachlor II, hexachlorobenzene, aldrin, p,p' - DDE, Δ - BHC (hexachlorobenzene), demeton - S - methyl sulfone, p,p' - DDD, lindane, p,p' - DDT and heptachlor sulfate. - **Food processing effect assessment**: - The influence of different food processing steps (such as cold - water rinsing, warm - water rinsing, soaking and fermentation) on pesticide residue levels was studied. - The results show that these processing steps can significantly reduce pesticide residue levels. For example, cold - water rinsing and warm - water rinsing have a significant removal effect on methoxychlor and α - chlordane. - **Risk characterization analysis**: - By calculating EDI, %TDI and HI, assess the health risks of the detected pesticide residues to consumers. - The results indicate that the concentrations of aldrin and dieldrin far exceed the safety thresholds, and the contents of hexachlorobenzene, lindane, aldrin, dieldrin and methoxychlor in staple foods may cause chronic toxicity. ### Conclusion - **Effect of the ban**: - The residue levels of most detected pesticides are low, and the detection rates and concentrations of most pesticides are low, which indicates that the ban has achieved significant results in reducing the use of these pesticides. - However, some pesticide residues still exist, and regulatory agencies need to take further measures to eliminate these risks. - **Importance of food processing**: - Basic food processing steps (such as rinsing, soaking and fermentation) can significantly reduce pesticide residue levels, thereby improving food safety. Through these studies, the paper provides important data support for the Nigerian government and relevant regulatory agencies, which is helpful for formulating more effective food safety policies.