Multi-source Data Fusion Improved the Potential of Proximal Fluorescence Sensors in Predicting Nitrogen Nutrition Status Across Winter Wheat Growth Stages

Qing Liu,Cuicun Wang,Jie Jiang,Jiancheng Wu,Xue Wang,Qiang Cao,Yongchao Tian,Yan Zhu,Weixing Cao,Xiaojun Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compag.2024.108786
IF: 8.3
2024-01-01
Computers and Electronics in Agriculture
Abstract:Rapid and accurate nitrogen (N) diagnosis plays a crucial role in precise N fertilizer management of wheat. However, most existing N diagnosis models based on proximal fluorescence sensors' indicators are confined to a single growth stage, thereby limiting the accuracy and universality of models. Therefore, this study aimed to construct and evaluate wheat N diagnosis models based on proximal fluorescence sensors across growth stages by fusing multi -source data. Six field experiments conducted over four years, involved diverse planting densities, wheat varieties, and N rates. These experiments were performed to investigate the relationship between optical indicators obtained from Dualex 4 and Multiplex 3, and both the plant N accumulation (PNA) and the N nutrition index (NNI). The dualex indicators were extended to the canopy level (canopy_dualex indicators) by the leaf area index (LAI). In addition to formulating N nutrition diagnostic models based on the three optical indicators solely, we further integrated meteorological factors, soil basic fertility, and cultivation practices to construct dynamic N diagnosis models coupling with machine learning algorithms. Fusing multi -source data significantly improved the R2, resulting in an increase of 0.20 and 0.29 when predicting PNA for dualex and multiplex, respectively. The canopy_dualex indicator consistently performed best in predicting both PNA (R2 = 0.75, RRMSE = 28.71 %) and NNI (R2 = 0.60, RRMSE = 24.62 %) among the three optical indicators. Moreover, the inclusion of LAI effectively addressed the overfitting issue observed in dualex when fusing multi -source data to construct the models. Consistency tests and ROC curve analyses provided robust evidence that canopy_dualex exhibited the highest consistency and the most powerful diagnostic ability. Additionally, multiplex demonstrated superior performance compared to dualex in predicting PNA and NNI, with higher R2 (0.46-0.50) and lower RRMSE (28.57 %-40.84 %). The results underscored that multi -source data fusion significantly improved the accuracy of universal N nutrition models for wheat across growth stages, leveraging proximal fluorescence sensors to cover the entire wheat growth process. This approach allows for the identification of N nutrition status at any given time, facilitating timely adjustments in N fertilizer management. From the two aspects of feature selection results of multi -source data fusion and the difficulty of obtaining data in the application, it is recommended that the first variable to be added in N nutrition diagnosis of is N application amount. If the target is PNA, the accumulated precipitation (APP) data is collected first. In order to obtain NNI, the soil total N content is considered first. Furthermore, this flexibility offers a convenient and promising option for practical agricultural production.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?