Single-Entity Protein Electrochemistry of Diffusion-Limited Enzymes

Ziwen Zhao,Nikolaos Kostopoulos,Sagar Ganguli,Paul Bergstrom,Alina Sekretareva
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-q12fw-v2
2024-03-04
Abstract:Single-entity electrochemistry has recently emerged as a promising method for label-free exploration of the catalytic functions of individual enzymes. However, skepticism within the scientific community regarding the applicability of the method for single enzyme measurements has arisen due to issues in the experimental data presented in the literature and limited theoretical modeling of such data. Here, we address these concerns through a thorough experimental investigation of two diffusion-limited enzymes, catalase and superoxide dismutase, employing a combination of protein film voltammetry and single-entity protein electrochemistry measurements. We then introduce a novel theoretical model for simulating the current responses, generated by the reduction of the product of the enzymatic reaction of single enzyme molecules at the electrode. This model is based on a combination of finite element simulations using COMSOL Multiphysics and random walk simulations. It incorporates the diffusion-limited enzymatic kinetics of the investigated enzymes and introduces a geometry that mimics the substrate diffusion channel of the enzyme. Our work demonstrates that the experimentally detected current signals align with the simulated current signals, affirming that they can be attributed to the catalytic activity of single enzymes detected via the product of the enzymatic reaction.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **Reliability and Applicability of Single - Enzyme Molecule Electrochemical Measurement**: Currently, single - entity protein electrochemistry (SEPE), as a label - free single - molecule detection method, is somewhat controversial in the scientific community. The main problems are the reliability of experimental data and the inadequacy of theoretical models. The paper verifies the effectiveness of the SEPE method through detailed experimental research and new theoretical models, especially for single - molecule measurements of diffusion - limited enzymes (such as catalase and superoxide dismutase). 2. **Inconsistency between Experimental Data and Theoretical Models**: There are large differences between the existing SEPE experimental data and theoretical predictions, especially in terms of the magnitude and stability of current signals. The paper explains these differences and verifies the reliability of experimental results by introducing new theoretical models, combined with finite - element simulation (using COMSOL Multiphysics) and random - walk simulation. 3. **The Problem of High Values of Single - Enzyme Molecule Catalytic Activity**: The single - enzyme molecule catalytic activity observed in experiments is much higher than the results of traditional ensemble measurement techniques. The paper explores the reasons for this phenomenon and proposes a new model, which can explain the experimental data without assuming large fluctuations in catalytic activity. 4. **Experimental Control and Verification**: In order to further verify the reliability of the SEPE method, the paper conducts strict control experiments, including collision - frequency - dependent experiments at different enzyme concentrations, to prove that the detected signals do indeed originate from single enzyme molecules. ### Specific Problem Analysis - **Reliability of Single - Enzyme Molecule Electrochemical Measurement**: - **Experimental Verification**: Through protein film voltammetry (PFV) and single - entity protein electrochemistry (SEPE) measurements, the electrochemical behaviors of catalase (CAT) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) under different conditions are verified. - **Theoretical Model**: A new theoretical model is proposed, which takes into account the diffusion - limited kinetics and geometric structure of the enzyme and can better explain the experimental data. - **Inconsistency between Experimental Data and Theoretical Models**: - **Model Improvement**: The partially active sphere model is introduced, taking into account the influence of the enzyme's geometric structure and diffusion channels, thereby more accurately simulating the electrochemical response of single - enzyme molecules. - **Parameter Optimization**: Through experimental measurements and literature data, the input parameters in the model, such as the diameter of the carbon fiber microelectrode, potential, initial species concentration, diffusion coefficient, and enzyme radius, are optimized. - **The Problem of High Values of Single - Enzyme Molecule Catalytic Activity**: - **Model Explanation**: The new model shows that even without considering large fluctuations in catalytic activity, the high - current signals observed in experiments can be explained. This is attributed to the influence of the enzyme's geometric structure and diffusion channels on the diffusion and electrochemical reduction of reaction products (such as O₂). - **Experimental Control and Verification**: - **Concentration - Dependent Experiment**: By changing the enzyme concentration and observing the change in collision frequency, it is verified that the detected signals do indeed originate from single enzyme molecules. - **pH - Dependent Experiment**: By conducting SEPE experiments at different pH values, the applicability of the model and the reliability of the experimental results are further verified. In conclusion, through a combination of experimental and theoretical methods, this paper systematically solves the key problems in single - enzyme molecule electrochemical measurement, providing a solid theoretical basis and experimental support for the application of the SEPE method.