Mineral Evolution Heralds a New Era for Mineralogy
Anhuai Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2138/am-2022-8414
2022-01-01
Abstract:In this issue of American Mineralogist, Hazen and Morrison (2022) propose that a mineral paragenetic mode can be defined as “a natural process by which a collection of atoms in solid and/or fluid form are reconfigured into one or more new solid forms.” The definition is based on a systematic summary of their research that spanned the last 15 years. By conducting “a systematic survey of 57 different paragenetic modes distributed among 5659 mineral species,” it was revealed that “patterns in the diversity and distribution of minerals related to their evolving formational environments” (Fig. 1). Important conclusions drawn from this research are as follows: (1) water plays a dominant role in the mineral diversity of Earth and is involved in the formation of more than 80% of mineral species; (2) life plays a direct or indirect role in the formation of ~50% of known mineral species while a third of known minerals form exclusively as a consequence of biological activities; (3) pyrite has the most different modes of formation of any mineral species; and (4) 41 rare chemical elements, which collectively account for only 1 in every 10 000 crustal atoms, are essential constituents of 42% of known minerals, i.e., rare elements play a disproportionate role in Earth’s mineral diversity. The methods and theories presented in this research serve as the basis for important advances in the field of mineral crystal chemistry and reflect the development and integration of systematicity, integrity, and evolvability in geosciences. Research on crystal chemistry emerged from the flourishing of conventional mineralogy. Mineralogists have accumulated abundant mineralogical knowledge through a long exploration history of chemical composition, crystal structure, physical properties, and occurrence and utilization of individual minerals over the past centuries. Case analyses, scientific summaries, and phenomena descriptions of inherent features constitute the fundamental methodologies for traditional mineralogy and geology. For example, French mineralogist Haüy (1822) did pioneering work in crystallography and discovered the periodic structure inside a crystal while examining the perfect rhombohedral shapes of broken calcite specimens. Mineral crystal chemistry, including research on crystal structure and chemical composition, is largely driven by advanced physical and chemical theories, methods, and techniques. Conversely, it is crystal chemistry that contributes greatly to the development of conventional mineralogy and even to that of physics and chemistry. A classic example is provided by Russian chemist Mendeleev (1869), who formulated the Periodic Law of elements as a result of his studies on mineral crystal chemistry. Mineral evolution research (Hazen et al. 2008), to some extent, has enriched mineral crystal chemistry. There is a distinct difference between geological and chemical research objects in both time and space scales. Chemists tend to focus on microscopic reactions that occur tens of thousands of times in a second, while geoscientists pay more attention to natural processes that occur once in tens of thousands of years on a macro level. Therefore, a systematic, integrated, and evolutionary methodology is critical for geology research. It can be said the new requirements of the burgeoning Earth system science have given rise to mineral evolution research. After accumulating a large amount of data, it is necessary not only to establish an overall cognition of the Earth but also to reveal the general laws of complex natural systems from multiple perspectives and, more importantly, to explore geological processes and evolution over the course of more than 4.6 billion years. In addition to the currently emphasized evolution of mineral assemblages and species, the chemical composition and crystal structure, as well as the resulting mineral properties, have evolved American Mineralogist, Volume 107, pages 1217–1218, 2022