Substituent-dependent spin-state switching in isomeric iron(II) complexes: from bi-stable spin-state switching with T1/2 centred at room temperature to trapped high-spin state

Senthil Kumar Kuppusamy,Lea Spieker,Benoît Heinrich,Heiko Wende,Mario Ruben,Asato Mizuno,Soma Salamon,Corinne Bailly
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2022-mnh4n-v2
2024-02-22
Abstract:Spin-state switching in iron(II) complexes composed of ligands featuring moderate ligand-field strength—for example, 2,6-bi(1H-pyrazol-1-yl)pyridine (BPP)—is dependent on many factors—examples include lattice solvent, counter anion, and substituent. Herein, we show that spin-state switching in isomeric iron(II) complexes (1·CH3CN and 2) composed of tridentate all nitrogen coordinating ligands—ethyl 2,6-bis(1H-pyrazol-1-yl)isonicotinate (BPP-COOEt, L1) and (2,6-di(1H-pyrazol-1-yl)pyridin-4-yl)methylacetate (BPP-CH2OCOMe, L2)—is controlled by the nature of substituent at the fourth position of the pyridine ring of the BPP skeleton. Complex 1·CH3CN, crystallized with acetonitrile solvent, undergoes abrupt and hysteretic spin-state switching, hence bistable switching, with a thermal hysteresis width (ΔT1/2) of 44 K and switching temperature (T1/2) = 298 K in the first cycle. Conversely, the isomeric counterpart of 1·CH3CN—complex 2—crystallized with no lattice solvent; the complex was trapped in the high-spin (HS) state upon cooling from 300 K. Molecular structures of the LS and HS forms of complex 1·CH3CN revealed that spin-state switching induces a pronounced angular distortion, creating an energy barrier separating the LS and HS states. Traversing the barrier requires substantial molecular rearrangement in the presence of constraints imposed by the crystal lattice, rendering the spin-state switching of 1·CH3CN hysteretic in the solid-state. The observation of bistable spin-state switching with T1/2 centred at room temperature for 1·CH3CN as well as the attribution of pronounced angular distortion and conformational variation of the COOEt substituent as causes behind the observed hysteretic spin-state switching indicates that technologically relevant spin-state switching profiles based on mononuclear iron(II) complexes can be obtained.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to reveal how to achieve bistable spin - state switching (SSS) at room temperature through molecular design by studying the spin - state switching characteristics of iron(II) complexes, especially isomeric iron(II) complexes affected by substituents. Specifically, the author hopes to understand and control the spin - state switching behavior in order to develop mononuclear iron(II) complexes with practical application value. ### Main problem summary: 1. **Control factors of spin - state switching**: Study the influence of different substituents on the spin - state switching of iron(II) complexes, especially how to regulate spin - state switching by changing the ligand structure. 2. **Bistable spin - state switching at room temperature**: Explore iron(II) complexes that can achieve bistable spin - state switching at room temperature and study the characteristics of their thermal hysteresis loops. 3. **Relationship between molecular structure and spin - state switching**: Analyze the changes in molecular structure between the low - spin state (LS) and the high - spin state (HS) by means such as single - crystal X - ray diffraction, and discuss the influence of these structural changes on spin - state switching. 4. **Practical application potential**: Evaluate the technical application prospects of these iron(II) complexes, especially their potential as magnetic molecular materials. ### Research background: - Spin - crossover (SCO) complexes are a class of molecular systems that can undergo spin - state switching under external stimuli (such as temperature, pressure, light, etc.). Among them, iron(II) complexes have attracted much attention because they may undergo spin - state switching near room temperature. - 2,6 - bis(1H - pyrazol - 1 - yl)pyridine (BPP) and its derivatives are common tridentate nitrogen ligands and can form complexes with spin - state switching characteristics with iron(II) ions. By modifying the substituents on the BPP skeleton, the properties of spin - state switching can be studied systematically. ### Research objects: - **Complex 1·CH₃CN**: An iron(II) complex formed by ligand L1 (ethyl 2,6 - bis(1H - pyrazol - 1 - yl)isonicotinate, BPP - COOEt), containing lattice solvent acetonitrile. - **Complex 2**: An iron(II) complex formed by ligand L2 ((2,6 - di(1H - pyrazol - 1 - yl)pyridin - 4 - yl)methylacetate, BPP - CH₂OCOMe), without lattice solvent. ### Key findings: - **Complex 1·CH₃CN**: It shows significant bistable spin - state switching, with a thermal hysteresis loop width of 44 K, a half - transition temperature (T₁/₂) of 298 K (room temperature), and is accompanied by obvious molecular distortion and substituent conformational changes. - **Complex 2**: It is fixed in the high - spin state during the cooling process, and no spin - state switching is observed, indicating that the difference in substituents has an important influence on spin - state switching. Through these studies, the author shows the possibility of designing iron(II) complexes with specific spin - state switching characteristics through molecular engineering, providing new ideas for further developing magnetic molecular materials with practical application value.