I Treated the Way You Treated Me: The Effect of Leader Hypocrisy on Employees' Voice Behavior
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s450359
IF: 3.974
2024-03-20
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Changlin Han, 1, &ast Xueling Wang, 1, &ast Wenjia Zhang, 2, &ast Mingyue Liu, 1, &ast Yuhuan Xia 3, &ast 1 School of Business, Qingdao University, Qingdao, Shandong, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Economics and Management, Beijing Jiaotong University, Beijing, People's Republic of China; 3 School of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Shandong University, Qingdao, Shandong, People's Republic of China &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Yuhuan Xia, School of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Shandong University, No. 72 Binhai Road, Jimo District, Qingdao, Shandong, 266237, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: In recent years, due to the increasingly prominent role of voice behavior in leader decision-making and organizational performance, such behavior has become a central topic for scholars. A majority of studies explore the "uphold" effects of multiple leader behavior toward the voice behavior; nonetheless, our study revealed the "undo" effect --- leader hypocrisy on voice behavior. Drawing on social cognitive theory, we investigated the relationship between leader hypocrisy and voice behavior, examined the mediating effects of cognition-based trust and affect-based trust, and the moderating effect of moral identity. Patients and Methods: We conducted a three-wave survey in a large Chinese corporation to test the hypothesized model. We collected 562 employees to participate in this survey. Results: The results show that leader hypocrisy negatively impacts employees' cognition-based and affect-based trust, and both types of trust mediate the relationship between leader hypocrisy and voice behavior, respectively. In the meantime, moral identity manifested the negative effect of leader hypocrisy on cognition-based and affect-based trust. Conclusion: Our research not only enriches the related research on leader hypocrisy and voice behavior but also uncovers the underlying mechanism through which leader hypocrisy affects voice behavior and the boundary conditions of this effect. Meanwhile, our research provides a theoretical reference for increasing employees' voice behavior and promoting the healthy development of enterprises. Keywords: leader hypocrisy, cognition-based trust, affect-based trust, voice behavior, moral identity, social cognitive theory The contemporary business circumstance with uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity, and mutability pushes organizations to adapt to the rapidly changing environment. These changes also present a considerable challenge to managers, as demands on them to collect, process, and consolidate information are more daunting than ever. In such a situation, employees' voice behavior, which refers to proactive behavior consenting to express thoughts and suggestions for upgrading the current organizational status, 1,2 becomes increasingly important to managers. 3 By catching the ideas and information provided by the voicers, managers are able to adjust their actions and come up with more effective improvements than before. 4 Besides benefiting managers and organizations, voice has many advantages. For individuals, such benefits include enhancing employees' work engagement, 5 job satisfaction, 6 creativity, 7 and work performance; 8 from an organizational perspective, voice behavior can increase the efficiency and accuracy of organizational decision, 9 organizations' creativity performance, 10 organizational teams' innovation level and team performance. 11 Being aware of the numerous benefits brought by voice behavior, researchers have put insight into antecedents of voice behavior from multiple perspectives, such as individual characteristics (eg, proactive personality, 12 cognition and affection, 13,14 capability variance 15 ), and organizational context and design. 16,17 As leaders play an essential role as receivers and executors of the voice, employees speak more or less largely depending on leadership style and leaders' characteristics. 1,4 However, despite that the decisive role of leaders in employee voice behavior has also been extensively confirmed, previous studies have largely concentrated on the impact of leadership (which captures comprehensive characteristics of leaders, such as humble leadership, 18 ethical leadership, 19 and servant leadership 20 ) but given insufficient consideration to the unique and specific behavioral traits of leaders. Considering that the primary goal of voice is to change curre -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary