Abstract:Emulation of the "target trial" (TT), a hypothetical pragmatic randomized controlled trial (RCT), using observational data can be used to mitigate issues commonly encountered in comparative effectiveness research (CER) when randomized trials are not logistically, ethically, or financially feasible. However, cardiovascular (CV) health research has been slow to adopt TT emulation. Here, we demonstrate the design and analysis of a TT emulation using electronic health records to study the comparative effectiveness of the addition of a disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drug (DMARD) to a regimen of methotrexate on CV events among rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. We used data from an electronic medical records-based cohort of RA patients from Northwestern Medicine to emulate the TT. Follow-up began 3 months after initial prescription of MTX (2000–2020) and included all available follow-up through June 30, 2020. Weighted pooled logistic regression was used to estimate differences in CVD risk and survival. Cloning was used to handle immortal time bias and weights to improve baseline and time-varying covariate imbalance. We identified 659 eligible people with RA with average follow-up of 46 months and 31 MACE events. The month 24 adjusted risk difference for MACE comparing initiation vs non-initiation of a DMARD was -1.47% (95% confidence interval [CI]: -4.74, 1.95%), and the marginal hazard ratio (HR) was 0.72 (95% CI: 0.71, 1.23). In analyses subject to immortal time bias, the HR was 0.62 (95% CI: 0.29–1.44). In this sample, we did not observe evidence of differences in risk of MACE, a finding that is compatible with previously published meta-analyses of RCTs. Thoughtful application of the TT framework provides opportunities to conduct CER in observational data. Benchmarking results of observational analyses to previously published RCTs can lend credibility to interpretation.

Re. Emulating a Target Trial of Interventions Initiated During Pregnancy With Healthcare Databases: The Example of COVID-19 Vaccination

Emulating a Target Trial of Interventions Initiated During Pregnancy with Healthcare Databases: The Example of COVID-19 Vaccination

Emulating a Target Trial of Interventions Initiated During Pregnancy With Healthcare Databases: The Example of COVID-19 Vaccination. The Authors Respond

Treatments for pregestational chronic conditions during pregnancy: emulating a target trial with a treatment decision design

Specifying a target trial protocol to estimate the effect of preconception treatment of periodontitis on time‐to‐pregnancy: A commentary and applied example

Emulating target trials of postexposure vaccines using observational data

TrialEmulation: An R Package to Emulate Target Trials for Causal Analysis of Observational Time-to-event Data

Target Trial Emulation: A Call for More Widespread Use

When exposure affects subgroup membership: Framing relevant causal questions in perinatal epidemiology and beyond

Effects Among the Affected

Identifying and estimating effects of sustained interventions under parallel trends assumptions

Target Trial Emulation for Evaluating Health Policy

Clinical trial emulation in nephrology

A Trial Emulation Approach for Policy Evaluations with Group-level Longitudinal Data

Trial emulation and survival analysis for disease incidence registers: a case study on the causal effect of pre-emptive kidney transplantation

Reference-trial-informed design to explore treatment effects in trial-underrepresented subgroups

Designing target trials using electronic health records: A case study of second-line disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs and cardiovascular disease outcomes in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Clinical Trials Impacted by the COVID-19 Pandemic: Adaptive Designs to the Rescue?

Introduction to target trial emulation in rehabilitation: a systematic approach to emulate a randomized controlled trial using observational data

Changing interim monitoring in response to internal clinical trial data

Adjusting for Selection Bias Due to Missing Eligibility Criteria in Emulated Target Trials