Investigating the Reliability and Interpretability of Machine Learning Frameworks for Chemical Retrosynthesis

Friedrich Hastedt,Rowan M. Bailey,Klaus Hellgardt,Sophia N. Yaliraki,Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona,Dongda Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-qdgnv-v3

2024-02-12

Abstract:Machine learning models for chemical retrosynthesis have attracted substantial interest in recent years. Unaddressed challenges, particularly the absence of robust evaluation metrics for performance comparison, and the lack of black-box interpretability, obscure model limitations and impede progress in the field. We present an automated benchmarking pipeline designed for effective model performance comparisons. With an emphasis on user-friendly design, we aim to streamline accessibility and facilitate utilisation within the research community. Additionally, we suggest and perform a new interpretability study to uncover the degree of chemical understanding acquired by retrosynthesis models. Our results reveal that frameworks based on chemical reaction rules yield the most diverse, chemically valid, and feasible reactions, whereas purely data-driven frameworks suffer from unfeasible and invalid predictions. The interpretability study emphasises that incorporating reaction rules not only enhances model performance but also improves interpretability. For simple molecules, we demonstrate that Graph Neural Networks identify relevant functional groups within the product molecule, providing thermodynamic stabilisation over the reactant precursors. In contrast, the popular Transformer fails to identify such crucial stabilisation. As the molecule and reaction mechanism grow more complex, both data-driven models propose unfeasible disconnections without offering a chemical rationale. We stress the importance of incorporating chemically meaningful descriptors within deep-learning models. Our study provides valuable guidance for the future development of retrosynthesis frameworks.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the reliability and interpretability issues of machine learning frameworks in chemical retrosynthesis. Currently, although machine learning models for retrosynthesis have received wide attention, the lack of robust evaluation metrics for performance comparison and the black-box nature of the models hinder the progress in this field. The researchers propose an automated benchmarking pipeline to effectively compare the performance of different models and emphasize user-friendliness to promote the utilization in the research community. In addition, they also conducted a novel study on interpretability to reveal the level of chemical understanding of retrosynthesis models. The research findings indicate that rule-based frameworks based on chemical reaction rules can generate the most diverse, chemically valid, and feasible reactions, while purely data-driven frameworks tend to produce infeasible and ineffective predictions. The interpretability study highlights that incorporating reaction rules not only improves model performance but also enhances interpretability. For simple molecules, graph neural networks can identify relevant functional groups in the product molecules and provide thermodynamic stability, while the popular Transformer failed to recognize this critical stability. As the complexity of molecules and reaction mechanisms increases, both data-driven models propose unreasonable fragmentation without providing chemical justifications. The paper emphasizes the importance of incorporating descriptors with chemical meanings into deep learning models, which provides valuable guidance for the future development of retrosynthesis frameworks. Keywords include chemical retrosynthesis, machine learning, interpretable artificial intelligence, graph neural networks, and Transformer. The remaining parts of the paper provide detailed explanations of the methods, results, and future research directions.

Investigating the Reliability and Interpretability of Machine Learning Frameworks for Chemical Retrosynthesis

Dissecting Errors in Machine Learning for Retrosynthesis: A Granular Metric Framework and Transformer-Based Model for More Informative Predictions

Holistic chemical evaluation reveals pitfalls in reaction prediction models

Bridging Chemical Knowledge and Machine Learning for Performance Prediction of Organic Synthesis.

Retrosynthesis prediction with an interpretable deep-learning framework based on molecular assembly tasks

MechRetro is a chemical-mechanism-driven graph learning framework for interpretable retrosynthesis prediction and pathway planning

Leveraging Reaction-aware Substructures for Retrosynthesis Analysis

Recent advances in deep learning for retrosynthesis

Decomposing Retrosynthesis into Reactive Center Prediction and Molecule Generation

Chimera: Accurate retrosynthesis prediction by ensembling models with diverse inductive biases

Retro-BLEU: Quantifying Chemical Plausibility of Retrosynthesis Routes through Reaction Template Sequence Analysis

Prediction of Organic Reaction Outcomes Using Machine Learning

Interpretable Machine Learning for Catalytic Materials Design toward Sustainability

Retrosynthesis prediction enhanced by in-silico reaction data augmentation

Machine Learning-Assisted Retrosynthesis Planning: Current Status and Future Prospects

Exploring Chemical Reaction Space with Machine Learning Models: Representation and Feature Perspective

Investigations into the efficiency of computer-aided synthesis planning

Reaction performance prediction with an extrapolative and interpretable graph model based on chemical knowledge

A Unified View of Deep Learning for Reaction and Retrosynthesis Prediction: Current Status and Future Challenges

Deep Retrosynthetic Reaction Prediction using Local Reactivity and Global Attention

A Machine Learning and Explainable AI Framework Tailored for Unbalanced Experimental Catalyst Discovery