Comparison of a New Prognostic System and Six Current Staging Systems in Predicting the Survival Rate of Patients with Advanced Hepatocellular Carcinoma Undergoing Loco-Regional Therapy.
Ying-Fen Hong,Zhan-hong Chen,Xing Li,Zhi-Huan Lin,Xiu-Rong Cai,Tian-tian Wang,Chang-Chang Jia,Qu Lin,Mingsheng Huang,Xiang-yuan Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1200/jco.2016.34.15_suppl.e15615
IF: 45.3
2016-01-01
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Abstract:e15615 Background: Prognosis of patients with advanced HCC(aHCC) is very poor even though they receive loco-regional therapy. We have established a new prognostic system called SYSU system (variables are listed below) and now we want to compare this new prognostic system and 6 current staging systems in predicting the survival rate of patients with aHCC undergoing loco-regional therapy. Methods: A total of 220 aHCC patients undergoing loco-regional therapy were analyzed. The methods of loco-regional therapy included transarterial chemotherapy with or without concomitant embolization, percutaneous ethanol injection except radical surgery and systemic treatment. Data were collected to classify patients according to our new system (SYSU system), Cancer of the Liver Italian Program (CLIP), Chinese University Prognostic Index staging system for HCC (CUPI), Chinese integrated score (CIS), Child-Pugh Score and TNM staging system at diagnosis. 1-year OS, 2-year OS and OS were the end points used in the analysis. Results: The median survival is 21.2 months. When predicting 1-year OS, AUC of CLIP, SYSU, CIS, TNM, CUPI and CHILD is 0.739, 0.720, 0.661, 0.654, 0.625 and 0.553. When predicting 2-year OS, AUC of CLIP, SYSU, CIS, CUPI, TNM and CHILD is 0.676, 0.674, 0.617, 0.583, 0.578,and 0.566. AUCs of CLIP and SYSU share similar at predicting 1-year and 2-year OS ( both P>0.05) , and they are both significantly higher than the other five staging systems. When predicting OS, likelihood ratio test show χ2 of CLIP, SYSU, TNM, CIS, CUPI and CHILD is 29.3, 26.7, 16.7, 15.8, 14.2 and 6.0. AIC of CLIP, SYSU, TNM, CIS, CUPI, and CHILD is 1343.4, 1346.2, 1354.4, 1356.7,1358.4 and 1366.6.The CLIP system and our SYSU system both have best performance in terms of discriminatory ability, homogeneity and monotonicity. Conclusions: Our SYSU system and CLIP are the best score systems in prediction of 1-year OS, 2-year OS and OS among the 7 systems analyzed for Chinese aHCC patients undergoing loco-regional therapy. A new prognostic system: SYSU system. 0 1 2 Child-Pugh A B C Tumor size ≤50% of the liver >50% of the liver Bun ≤8.9 >8.9 AFP ≤400 >400 Portal vein thrombosis No Yes