The First-Review Effect: Interdependence Between Volume and Valence of Online Consumer Reviews

Sungsik Park,Woochoel Shin,Jinhong Xie

2016-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper uncovers the striking power of a product’s first consumer review. Our analytical model suggests that two key metrics of online consumer reviews, valence and volume, are not independent, but instead, evolve interdependently. This interdependence forms a mechanism to transfer a (dis)advantage from a product’s first review to both a long-lasting (dis)advantage in future WOM valence and an increasing (dis)advantage in future WOM volume. As a result, a single consumer review can significantly influence the fate of a given product. These theoretical predictions, while seemingly unlikely, are supported by our empirical investigations. For example, more than thirty percent of vacuum cleaner models offered by both amazon.com and bestbuy.com receive first reviews of opposite valence on the two websites. Those with a negative first review subsequently suffer a loss in both valence and volume vis-a-vis their counterparts with a positive first review, even after 36 months. More strikingly, the first-review effect on WOM volume increases over time. Our findings underscore a crucial weakness in the consumer review mechanism: as a consumption-based information source, it creates an information-availability bias. Specifically, when a quality product is denigrated by its first review and thus suffers low initial sales, it loses opportunity to correct this negative bias via subsequent reviews. This weakness in the consumer reviews not only harms sellers’ profits but also potentially deprives consumers of the chance to enjoy high-quality products. These findings have substantial implications for online sellers, ecommerce platform providers, and consumers.