Corporate Social Responsibility Practices in Chinese Hotel Industry: A Content Analysis of Public CSR Information of Top 15 Chinese Hotel-management Companies
PENG Xuerong,WEI Jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-5006.2013.03.007
2013-01-01
Abstract:With the rapid development of corporate social responsibility(CSR) practices in the Chinese hotel industry(which include the green hotel movement,environmental protection and charitable donations),researchers are increasingly interested in CSR within this industry from various angles and different theoretical perspectives.Some researchers have explored the antecedent or motivation of CSR practices within Chinese hotel enterprises.These researchers have found that CSR practices are working positively with hotel managerial ethics,institutional pressures and market orientation.Other researchers pay attention to the mechanisms of CSR behavior and examine how CSR practices are actually carried out in hotel enterprises.Nevertheless,little theoretical attention has been paid to understanding what CSR practices implemented in Chinese hotels really achieve.This paper aims to fill this gap by focusing on CSR reports from top Chinese hotel-management companies.Using content analysis of public CSR information(which includes data from independent CSR or sustainability reports,official hotel websites and CSR news) from the top 15 Chinese hotel-management companies(rated by room number in 2010),we found several key CSR characteristics.First,the main CSR practices of top Chinese hotel-management companies are charitable donations(particularly for disaster relief),volunteer activities,green hotel practices and the reduction of energy consumption.Second,providing accommodation and support for governmental activities or hospitality is considered an important part of hotel CSR for central and local governments.This reflects the unique combination of CSR characteristics in the Chinese hotel industry experienced in a transitional economic environment.Third,Chinese hotel-management companies feel more responsibility towards the community and society,the environment,employees,governments and customers than suppliers,competitors or creditors.This partly reflects CSR's global nature,which goes beyond the law.Fourthly,Chinese hotel-management companies are beginning to link CSR to their core business.This means strategic CSR practices are emerging in the Chinese hotel industry.Finally,disclosure of CSR information by hotel management companies is more likely to be made by official hotel website news reports and less likely to be made by independent CSR reports or CSR columns within hotel websites. This study makes two important theoretical contributions.It adds to CSR literature through content analysis of CSR information disclosed by top hotel management companies in China,one of the world's most important emerging economies.The findings from this study assist understanding CSR behaviors in developing countries.Second,this paper contributes to hotel management literature.Our findings help us understand the behavior of Chinese hotel-management companies and compare them with hotel enterprises in other countries,particularly in developed economies. Our study also has implications for managers.Our results can assist group and independent hotel managers in understanding hotel CSR practices and improve their CSR awareness.This can help hotels focus on CSR information disclosure and improve the quality and channels of CSR information disclosure.Our findings can also stimulate mutual CSR knowledge exchange and transfer between hotel enterprises and improve CSR cognition and practice levels across the entire hotel industry.Further,our study can also give insights to managers in other service industries because CSR practices within the hotel industry are more advanced than within other service industries. This study has two limitations.The first is that public CSR information is constantly evolving.This paper's content analysis was performed during the first quarter of 2012.Information may have since changed to include or dismiss data found in this study.Second,public CSR information may have a 'social desirability' problem,meaning published material may more likely include 'good news' stories.