Scale and Status of Nuclear Power Plant Severe Accident Research

Yanhua Yang,XU Ji-jun

2003-01-01

Abstract:Nearly twenty years,a lot of resources have been devoted to understand the mecha- nism of the phenomena in nuclear severe accidents,to find the consequences resulted by these phenomena and to establish the countermeasures for safety.The research scales and the current re- search status are introduced.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Analysis on Status and Trends of Global Nuclear Safety Framework in Recent Years

Xin-yuan SHEN,Zhi-bin CHEN,Hai-xia WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3772/j.issn.1009-8623.2016.08.012

2016-01-01

Abstract:As nuclear accidents may bring supranational hazards, international community has realized the necessity of strengthen international cooperation in nuclear and radiation safety. Thus IAEA and the international community gradually built up an international cooperation system—Global Nuclear Safety Framework, which contains factors of legal regime, international standards, implementation mechanisms, information exchange and sharing platforms, etc., to improve the international cooperative system of global nuclear safety. This paper analyzes the concept of Global Nuclear Safety Framework from its content, composition, status and development trends, to draw inspiration for China’s nuclear safety and participation in the international cooperation.
Major Technical Issues in Developing Emergency Plans for Research Reactors

Q(U) Jingyuan,WU Zhongwang,LIU Yuanzhong,XI Shuren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-0054.2000.02.016

2000-01-01

Abstract:Common international practices for the development of emergency response plans and preparedness plans for research reactors, especially the methodologies suggested by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC), have been adopted in China. This paper reviews the experience gained in this country in recent years in this field. The major technical issues discussed include (1) technical basis for defining emergency status levels, (2) determination of emergency zones, (3) quantification of emergency action levels, (4) consideration of severe accidents, and (5) emergency planning and preparedness for multiple reactors on a single site. The activities and experience gained in the emergency management of research reactors operated in Institute of Nuclear Energy Technology of Tsinghua University are also briefly discussed.
Countermeasures of Severe Accident in PWR

ZHANG Song,ZHUANG Wen-cui,ZANG Xi-nian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0258-0926.2007.06.024

2007-01-01

Abstract:The process and phenomena of the severe accident is described in this paper, and the severe accident management is analyzed. The WOG SAMG is systemically introduced, as well as its structure:the guidelines of MCR, the guidelines of TSC, CAs, and SAEGs. The logic of the accident management strategies of WOG SAMG is summarized and some suggestions for the research of accident management in China are provided.
China's response to nuclear safety pre- and post-Fukushima: An interdisciplinary analysis

Jacqueline C.K. Lam,Lawrence Y.L. Cheung,Yang Han,Shanshan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2021.112002

IF: 16.799

2022-04-01

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

Abstract:The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster has rekindled the world's attention to nuclear safety following the devastating nuclear accidents that occurred in the Three Mile Island and Chernobyl. As China continues to expand in nuclear power development, how it views and responds to nuclear safety carries significant implications on its nuclear safety and security in the future. This paper examines the Chinese authorities' response to nuclear safety pre- and post-Fukushima, based on (1) a longitudinal big-data discourse analysis of the Chinese newspaper articles published during the period 2008–2017, and (2) an in-depth comprehensive review of nuclear safety performance and safety governance based on credential and publicly available documents and websites, both locally and internationally. Our assessment reveals that (i) China's concerns over nuclear safety and accident surged immediately following the Fukushima crisis. Increasing attention towards nuclear emergency response has been observed since 2014, (ii) China has displayed strengths in reactor design and safety operation, and (iii) its safety governance has been constrained by institutional fragmentation, inadequate transparency, inadequate safety professionals, lack of a strong safety culture, amid its ongoing plans to increase nuclear capacity three-fold by 2050. To improve nuclear safety, China may further strengthen its safety standards, safety management and monitoring, improve institutional arrangements, increase the ratio of safety professionals, intensify its safety culture and transparency, develop process-based safety regulations, and champion international collaboration to keep itself abreast of the latest international best practices.

energy & fuels,green & sustainable science & technology
Application Mode of Severe Accidents Criteria to the Partition of Nuclear Power Plant Emergency Planning Zone

HUANG Ting,QU Jingyuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3981/j.issn.1000-7857.2011.09.002

2011-01-01

Abstract:As the technical criteria,it is required that the severe accident sequences should be considered in the partition of nuclear power plants Emergency Planning Zone(EPZ).In the relevant national standards and nuclear safety guide rules,the dose criteria involving 'majority severe accident sequences' and 'the severest accident sequences' are proposed.However,in the actual applications of these criteria,there might be some different understanding to the concept of 'majority severe accident sequences' and 'the severest accident sequences'.The source terms of PWR1—PWR7 release categories in WASH1400 are selected as the referenced source terms,and the individual consequence of each source term and the weighted average of these consequences are calculated and analyzed by using MACCS code.Then the impacts of the results of two different calculation approaches on EPZ size are compared with each other.The conclusion shows that the weighted average of the severe accident spectrum consequences can basically reflect the assessment results of each severe accident consequence and the consideration for emergency planning cost to a certain extension.This means that using the weighted average of the severe accident spectrum consequences as the technical criteria for the partition of EPZ can better embody the trade-off principle between the risk mitigation and cost.
THE CURRENT RESEARCH STATUS AND TECHNICAL DEVELOPMENT FRAMEWORK OF MULTI-REACTOR PROBABILISTIC CONSEQUENCE ASSESSMENT

Hongchun Ding,Jiejuan Tong,Liguo Zhang,Lu Wang,Ruiying Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/icone25-66365

2017-01-01

Abstract:The Fukushima Daiichi Accident in March 2011 gave rise to public attention on the possibility and severity of multi reactor accident, i.e. multiple reactors and spent fuel pools on one site affected by an accident simultaneously or one after the other. Multi-reactor sites are a common phenomenon among nuclear development countries. The current safety assessment and regulatory requirements are established in the light of one reactor in a site. However, the reactors in a site are not independent with each other. Due to these dependencies, there are potential risk comes from multi-reactor accidents. Under this condition, many non-linear components will be involved into the evaluation of radiological consequences. Thus the Site Probabilistic Risk Assessment (SPRA) is not the linear superposition of PRAs in each reactor. From this point of view, SPRA should be developed according to the characteristics of multi-reactor nuclear accidents so as to quantitatively assess the risk of multi-reactor sites. Probabilistic Consequence Assessment (PCA) as part of the Level 3 PRA estimates the offsite consequence combined with the source term and occurrence frequency of accident given by the Level 2 PRA. PCA is an important part and tool to evaluate the overall social risk and verify the safety goals of NPPs. Multi-reactor PCA is an essential technical tool to discuss the multi-reactor issues, such as the verification of safety goal and the development of emergency planning zone (EPZ) in multi-reactor sites. In this paper, the current research status about multi-reactor PCA in main nuclear countries and nuclear organizations are elaborated and a technical development framework is proposed aimed at the multi-reactor site based on MELCOR Accident Consequence Code System (MACCS).
The changing risk perception towards nuclear power in China after the Fukushima nuclear accident in Japan

Lei Huang,Ruoying He,Qianqi Yang,Jin Chen,Ying Zhou,James K. Hammitt,Xi Lu,Jun Bi,Yang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2018.05.007

IF: 9

2018-01-01

Energy Policy

Abstract:Gradual recovery of Chinese nuclear power industry and its increasingly important position in the world have created a need to understand how public attitudes towards nuclear power changed after the Fukushima nuclear accident in Japan (FNAJ). To address this need, we augment our previous work to include data from a new survey conducted three years after the FNAJ in the same study area. The results showed that three years after the FNAJ, factor knowledge continued to increase, whereas the other four perception factors acceptance, risk, benefit, and trust had recovered from their post-FNAJ changes to different degrees. The sensitive groups whose acceptance declined more after the FNAJ showed a greater increase as time passed. It was also found that median acceptable frequency for level 1 nuclear events (anomaly) showed little change from Survey 2 to Survey 3, while tolerance of more severe events (incidents and serious incidents) has decreased substantially. The overall recovery of public acceptance shown in our study was in line with the nuclear development trend of China. But more efforts still need to be made to improve nuclear safety and risk communication.
Risk Assessment for Cascading Failures of Complex Power System

LI Rong-rong,ZHANG Ye,JIANG Quan-yuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-3673.2006.10.004

2006-01-01

Abstract:Cascading failures in power system are rare processes but often bring severe consequences. Severe cascading failures may cause large scale blackouts or even system collapse. The authors present an approach to evaluate the risk of cascading failures for complex power system, which simulates the general expansion process of cascading failures and associates the occurrence probability of cascading failures with their consequences, then a quantitative risk index is proposed by which the hidden trouble of power system can be discovered and the potential safety hazard can be revealed. On this basis, the software for risk assessment of cascading failures in power system is developed according to risk theory. Taking NPCC 48-machine system for example, the simulation result shows that the proposed method is advanced and effective.
Research on condition assessment of nuclear power systems based on fault severity and fault harmfulness

Haotong Wang,Yanjun Li,Chaojing Lin,Siyuan Yang,Guolong Li,Shengdi Sun,Ye Tian,Jianxin Shi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2024.133396

IF: 9

2024-10-14

Energy

Abstract:Obtaining real time quantitative condition assessment results is a focus in the field of nuclear power system PHM. The existing researches on the nuclear power system condition assessment based on the Multi-Criteria Decision-Making framework do not consider the faults perniciousness differences. This leads to the assessment results relying on the system status deviation degrees(severity), and the weighting and aggregation processes cannot effectively reflect the differences in the consequences and risks of different faults, which represent the faults harmfulness. A quantitative assessment method based on fault severity and fault harmfulness is proposed to address this issue. The novel method quantifies the fault severity based on the similarity principle while diagnosing system faults, and then analyzes the devices mainly affected by various faults to quantifies the harmfulness. Combining the system status deviation degrees(severity), the devices and parameters importance, and the differences in faults harmfulness, the novel method aggregates comprehensive system condition assessment results. Based on a widely recognized nuclear power system faults dataset, the novel method was compared with other methods. The conclusion is that the novel method considers the differences in the faults harmfulness, resulting in more reasonable assessment results and avoiding insufficient or excessive warnings.

energy & fuels,thermodynamics
Some Issues in the Emergency Plan of Advanced Reactors

黄挺,曲静原

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-7857.2009.23.019

2009-01-01

Abstract:Emergency planning is an important component in the strategy of defense in-depth for nuclear safety. As far as the current nuclear power plants in operation over the world are concerned, enhanced safety features are integrated in the design of advanced reactors. For example, their probabilities of occurrence of severe accidents are very low. The time delay before the release of radioactivity into the environment after the initiation of an accident would be considerably long. Based in part on such considerations, the nuclear industry expects that nuclear safety authorities would take this into account when making decisions about emergency planning of advanced reactors. Preferably, the current relevant requirements concerning emergency planning could be relaxed when applied to advanced reactors, and the emergency planning be simplified. This paper presents first the general approach currently used to estimate the size of emergency planning zone. Then the current status of studies on emergency planning of advanced reactors is reviewed. Finally, important issues which should be carefully investigated in the decision making of emergency planning of advanced reactors are discussed.
Progress in Treatment Processes of Radioactive Wastewater from Nuclear Accident

Cai Xuan,Liu Yan,Zhang Yun,Liu Xiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14159/j.cnki.0441-3776.2012.06.001

2012-01-01

Chemistry

Abstract:Nuclear accidents might do great harm to the safety and health of human beings and the environment.In order to control the spread of radioactive matter,we should place enough emphasis on effective treatment and disposal of radioactive wastewater.This article summarized the treatment experience of Chernobyl nuclear explosion and Fukushima nuclear leakage in Japan,listed some effective treatment processes recommended by USEPA and UKHPA,and reviewed the research progress of adsorption,ion exchange,membrane separation and combined processes,which might offer China some reference in the establishment and improvement of radioactive wastewater treatment and disposal after nuclear accident.
Research on Improved Seismic Instrumentation System for Nuclear Power Plants

Liang Li,Xiuli Du,Rong Pan,Xiuyun Zhu,Haiyan Luan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en14144262

IF: 3.2

2021-07-14

Energies

Abstract:According to the requirements of nuclear safety regulations, nuclear power plants must be equipped with seismic instrumentation systems, which are mainly used for monitoring alarm and automatic shutdown alarm during an earthquake. Both the second and third generation NPPs adopt Peak Ground Acceleration (PGA). However, among the seismic acceleration characteristics, isolated and prominent single high frequency acceleration peaks have no decisive influence on the seismic response. Especially when the earthquake monitoring alarm is at 1 out of 7, it is likely to cause a false alarm or false shutdown. In addition, it usually takes one month or more for the NPPs to restart after the shutdown. In this paper, an improved seismic instrumentation system based on the existing system is proposed. For high intensity areas, three components resultant acceleration is used to judge the 2 out of 4 logic of the automatic seismic trip system(ASTS). For low intensity areas, the seismic failure level is evaluated quickly by using three components resultant acceleration, seismic instrument intensity, cumulative absolute velocity, floor response spectrum and other multi-parameters, avoiding unnecessary and long-term shutdown inspection.

energy & fuels
Technical research on rapid source term calculation and prediction technology of nuclear accidents based on Bayesian network

Mingliang Xie,Yuqing Chen,Lei Yu,Wei Wei,Boyu Chen,Zhengquan Xie,Xueyan Hou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00223131.2023.2294193

IF: 1.126

2023-12-19

Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology

Abstract:How to evaluate and predict potential source terms quickly and effectively is very important for emergency response. In this paper, the traditional forward analysis calculation based on deterministic method was combined with probability theory calculation, and a large number of typical accident sequences were calculated with severe accident analysis software to obtain data of source terms. According to expert knowledge base, probabilistic safety analysis, and other information, a model of nuclear power plant was established based on Bayesian network algorithm, so as to carry out researches on rapid source term calculation and prediction methods. Based on the Bayesian network model of a specific power plant and the pre-calculated source term results of typical accident scenarios, the best available knowledge and observation results of events were used to estimate the relevant typical source terms and their possibilities, which provide a strong basis for effectively grasping and predicting the accident process, quickly predicting source terms and release characteristics of radioactive materials, and quickly and accurately evaluating the radioactive consequences.

nuclear science & technology
Resilient Design in Nuclear Energy: Critical Lessons from a Cross-Disciplinary Review of the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Accident

Ali Ayoub,Haruko Wainwright,Giovanni Sansavini,Randall Gauntt,Kimiaki Saito

2023-03-16

Abstract:Nuclear energy has been gaining momentum recently as one of the solutions to tackle climate change. However, significant environmental and health-risk concerns remain associated with potential accidents. Despite significant preventive efforts, we must acknowledge that accidents may happen and, therefore, develop strategies and technologies for mitigating their consequences. In this paper, we review the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Plant accident, synthesize the time series and accident progressions across relevant disciplines, including in-plant physics and engineering systems, operators' actions, emergency responses, meteorology, radionuclide release and transport, land contamination, and health impacts. In light of the latest observations and simulation studies, we identify three key factors that exacerbated the consequences of the accident: (1) the failure of Unit 2 containment venting, (2) the insufficient integration of radiation measurements and meteorology data in the evacuation strategy, and (3) the limited risk assessment and emergency preparedness. We propose new research and development directions to improve the resilience of nuclear power plants, including (1) meteorology-informed proactive venting, (2) machine learning-enabled adaptive evacuation zones, and (3) comprehensive risk-informed emergency planning while leveraging the experience from responses to other disasters.

Physics and Society
Severe Accident Sequence Screening Criteria for Nuclear Power Plant

刘涛,玉宇,童节娟,赵军

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-7857.2009.19.007

2009-01-01

Abstract:Severe accidents prevention and mitigation is an important safety issue for new generation Nuclear Power Plant (NPP). This paper mainly focuses on the severe accident dominant sequences screening criteria when performing NPP severe accident management and study,including qualitative and quantitative criteria and their understanding. On this basis,a set of severe accident dominant sequence screening criteria is recommended for Chinese nuclear power plant severe accident study. Using this set of criteria to Advanced Passive Pressurized water reactor (AP1000) standard design is also attempted to show criteria's applicability. It is shown that severe accident sequence screening criteria should be described both qualitatively and quantitatively. From the qualitative point of view,the selection of severe accidents should be based on nuclear power plant state definition. Sequences which may lead to core damage or containment bypass and have most serious consequences in the range of beyond design basis accidents should be selected. From the quantitative point of view,absolute and relative values corresponding to severe accidents risk should be identified. At the same time,steep side effect combined with the outcomes of deterministic analysis and engineering experience should be considered. The screening results derived from the proposed screening criteria application on advanced reactor AP1000 are basically consistent with that given in AP1000 probabilistic safety assessment report.
Evaluation on nuclear emergency response strategies in the Asia-Pacific region

Fei Li,Jing Wang,Hui Li,Qian Hu,Wenxuan Dan,Liangquan Ge,David Cohen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijcip.2021.100447

IF: 3.683

2021-09-01

International Journal of Critical Infrastructure Protection

Abstract:<p>The safe use of nuclear energy has always been one of the vital factors hindering the development of nuclear energy. Especially after the Chernobyl Disaster in 1986 and the Fukushima nuclear power plant accident in 2011, the attitude of the government and the public towards the safe handling of nuclear power has become increasingly negative. International discussions on the emergency decision of nuclear accidents have never ceased, and the process of dealing with the accidents' aftermath is still difficult. Therefore, it is worth researching on the trend, effectiveness and perfection of the nuclear emergency response strategies issued by the government. This article selected the Asia-Pacific region as the research object, deeply reviewed the optimization policy and management of Australia, China, Thailand, Russia and other countries since 1953. With the constantly innovation of nuclear technology, this work is of great significance to formulate relevant policies and to improve the global nuclear emergency response strategies in the future.</p>

engineering, multidisciplinary,computer science, information systems
Research progress of hydrogen behaviors in nuclear power plant containment under severe accident conditions

Feng Liu,Zhongning Sun,Ming Ding,Haozhi Bian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2021.08.151

IF: 7.2

2021-10-01

International Journal of Hydrogen Energy

Abstract:Severe accident in a water-cooled nuclear power plant may lead to the production and release of hydrogen. If hydrogen forms flammable gas with air and steam in the containment, it may trigger more serious hydrogen explosion accident, threaten the integrity of the equipment and the containment. The behavioral characteristics of hydrogen under severe accident conditions become primarily responsible for the assessment of combustion risk. This review paper first identifies and describes various key physical phenomena associated to hydrogen behavior in the containment during a severe accident from four main aspects, including the source of hydrogen, hydrogen transport, combustion, and risk mitigation. The typical release process of hydrogen, the combustion limits of hydrogen and main risk mitigation measures are clarified comprehensively. Moreover, representative experimental facilities, related tests and key conclusions are introduced emphatically, which can provide specific guidance for future and ongoing related experimental research. Additionally, through the analysis of corresponding typical simulation studies based on LP method and CFD method, numerical methods suitable for various key phenomena are summarized and recommended. Currently, associated models realized in codes have limitations for predicting hydrogen behavior under certain conditions, which are mainly derived from the coupling effect of complex factors such as condensation, jets, and flame propagation, etc. The applicability and uncertainty of the models in these situations still need to be further evaluated and developed.

energy & fuels,electrochemistry,chemistry, physical
Consequences of the Fukushima Accident: A Preliminary Assessment and Discussion

张立国,曹建主,薛大知,曲静原,童节娟

2012-01-01

Abstract:Tsunami due to the earthquake in East Japan Sea eventually leaded to a severe nuclear accident in Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant. This event immediately became the focus of the whole world. The work to roughly evaluate and predict the consequence of this nuclear accident is summarized in this paper and the work actually provides valuable information in predicting the scale and severity of the accident comparing to the published information on the accident thereafter.
Scaling Study for Experimental Test of Advanced Reactor Analysis of Passive Feature of Containment and Its Simulation Hierarchy

Sheng-qiang LI,Wei-hua LI,Sheng-yao JIANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0258-0926.2013.02.022

2013-01-01

Abstract:Different containment safety features are analyzed. Combined with the accident process analysis and physical model classification, a containment system analysis hierarchy, which can be applied to advanced containment system simulation and experimental verification, is built. Different physical models, experimental methodology, scaling criteria, PIRT, mathematical models and test process logic are included. It attempts to provide theoretical support and design reference for future containment system characteristics verification experiments. It is also applicable for the system simulation, including complex coupling of physical phenomena and processes.
Health Diagnosis of Nuclear Power Plant

Wangyu Xue,Xiu Li,Biqing Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1729881419880654

IF: 1.714

2019-01-01

International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems

Abstract:At present, nuclear power plant is developing rapidly, and its application has been involved in many aspects including life, military, industry and many other important fields, bringing benefits to people’s life. However, the nuclear power plant has a relatively special structure. Once a safety accident occurs, the consequences will be unimaginable, and the cost of its operation and maintenance will be relatively high. Therefore, how to effectively diagnose the health status of the nuclear power plant is an urgent problem to be solved. On the above-mentioned research background, we need to study nuclear power plant health diagnosis method. Considering the characteristic of the nuclear power plant system and special failure mode, both the safety and economy, a health condition diagnosis method based on analytic hierarchy process and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method is proposed for the structural characteristics and functional characteristics of nuclear power plants. According to the special failure mode and complex system structure of nuclear power plant, the evaluation index system based on failure mode is constructed by laying the system using the hierarchical analysis method, and the system is scored by fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. The health status makes a coarse-grained diagnosis and provides a reference for the development of the operation and maintenance strategy.

Scale and Status of Nuclear Power Plant Severe Accident Research

Analysis on Status and Trends of Global Nuclear Safety Framework in Recent Years

Major Technical Issues in Developing Emergency Plans for Research Reactors

Countermeasures of Severe Accident in PWR

China's response to nuclear safety pre- and post-Fukushima: An interdisciplinary analysis

Application Mode of Severe Accidents Criteria to the Partition of Nuclear Power Plant Emergency Planning Zone

THE CURRENT RESEARCH STATUS AND TECHNICAL DEVELOPMENT FRAMEWORK OF MULTI-REACTOR PROBABILISTIC CONSEQUENCE ASSESSMENT

The changing risk perception towards nuclear power in China after the Fukushima nuclear accident in Japan

Risk Assessment for Cascading Failures of Complex Power System

Research on condition assessment of nuclear power systems based on fault severity and fault harmfulness

Some Issues in the Emergency Plan of Advanced Reactors

Progress in Treatment Processes of Radioactive Wastewater from Nuclear Accident

Research on Improved Seismic Instrumentation System for Nuclear Power Plants

Technical research on rapid source term calculation and prediction technology of nuclear accidents based on Bayesian network

Resilient Design in Nuclear Energy: Critical Lessons from a Cross-Disciplinary Review of the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Accident

Severe Accident Sequence Screening Criteria for Nuclear Power Plant

Evaluation on nuclear emergency response strategies in the Asia-Pacific region

Research progress of hydrogen behaviors in nuclear power plant containment under severe accident conditions

Consequences of the Fukushima Accident: A Preliminary Assessment and Discussion

Scaling Study for Experimental Test of Advanced Reactor Analysis of Passive Feature of Containment and Its Simulation Hierarchy

Health Diagnosis of Nuclear Power Plant