Comparison Between Journal of Academic Libraries and College & Research Libraries

Lei Zhang

IF: 8.1

2012-01-01

Information Sciences

Abstract:Journal of Academic Libraries and College Research Libraries are college research journals of China and the United States.By comparing the topics between these two journals,we can learn the differences and research focues.The analysis will be valuable to editors of Chinese college journals.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Comparative Study of Chinese-English Scientific Topic Ranking Correlations: Computer Science Perspective

Zhuoren Jiang,Liangcai Gao,Zhao Star,Xiaozhong Liu,Ke Yuan,Zhi Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3772/j.issn.1000-0135.2017.09.008

2017-01-01

Abstract:Topic ranking is an important issue for information retrieval and organization, and in this study, we con-ducted a comprehensive exploration of this issue from static global and dynamic historical perspectives, focusing on a comparative study of Chinese-English scientific topic rank correlations in each dataset, which was based on bibli-ometrics such as the frequency, number of citations, and PageRank value. In the experiment, which was conducted on an English dataset extracted from the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) and a Chinese dataset extracted from the Wanfang knowledge platform, the correlation relationships of Chinese and English topic rankings were re-vealed and compared using different ranking methods in different historical stages, as well as a dynamic change in the features of different correlation relationships. The experiment results show that, at the different historical stages, the Chinese and English topic rankings using different ranking methods all have positive correlations, and that an English topic ranking in a certain historical stage, with the development of time, will have increasing positive correlations with the Chinese topic rankings. Different ranking methods will change the time range of this increasingly positive correlation effect.
Comparison and Analysis of Chinese Journal of Medical Education in Different Period

LI Xiao-xia,GENG Min-jian,GAN Ye-hua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-677x.2009.05.023

2009-01-01

Abstract:By comparing and analyzing literatures of Chinese Journal of Medical Education in different period,this paper analyzed the differences and similarities on the constitutes of the literatures,the authors,different funds supporting,using vary statistic methods,citation of all kinds of references.As an important medical education journal in China,Chinese Journal of Medical Education had improved the quality further since 2006,and at the same time the author pointed out some disadvantages and suggestions.
A Comparative Study of Educational Research in China and the United States

Yong Zhao,Gaoming Zhang,Wenzhong (Eric) Yang,David Kirkland,Xue Han,Jianwei Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02188790701849826

IF: 1.478

2008-01-01

Asia Pacific Journal of Education

Abstract:This article examines one major research journal from China and one from the United States. The study compares the two journals with regard to three questions: 1) Who is doing research published in the journals? 2) What are the major issues and concerns represented in the journals? 3) What research methodologies are favoured in the journals? The authors believe that understanding another country's educational research practices, through addressing these questions, can better enable domestic researchers, educators and policymakers to acknowledge the major educational concerns and issues that exist across countries. As boundaries between national borders continue to blur, this understanding can help educational researchers better interpret and present their findings with greater international relevance.
Analysis on the Application of Comparative Method in Library Science Research in China from 2002 to 2008

Wang Xiufen,Liu Ziheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-6610.2009.05.001

2009-01-01

Abstract:This article makes a statistical analysis of papers using comparative method included in core journals of library and information science,which covered by CNKI from 2002 to 2008.Meanwhile,in order to see present situation and the features,it concentrates on the aspects of papers' amount,research subjects and the scope of research and so on.Finally,the authors put forward suggestions so as to improve the level of using comparative method.
Comparative Analysis of the Retrieval Functions of China Journal Database and Its Influence Factors

张玲

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-7490.2001.02.014

2001-01-01

Abstract:Based on the retrieval function of the Chinese Journal Database and the China Journal Net Bibliography and Abstract Database, the article analyzes the retrieval results of the two databases and their influence factors for the same retrieval missions. The article also discusses how to construct and evaluate a database.
A Comparison between A Guide to the Core Journal of China and Chinese Science Citation Database

Ma Jingdi,Miao Jiading,Zhang Xiangrong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0252-3116.2006.04.033

2006-01-01

Abstract:The core journals recorded in A Guide to the Core Journal of China and the source journals evaluated by Chinese Science Citation Database are analyzed and compared according to the research areas of natural science, medical science, agriculture and engineering. Then the paper reveals the subject distribution features of the core and source journals recorded. In addition, the paper also mentions the problems need be considered when using them as academic evaluation and journal evaluation indexes.
Comparative Study of Faculty of American and China's Institute of Library and Information Science

Shudan Zheng,Weina Hua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13366/j.dik.2011.03.018

2011-01-01

Abstract:This paper presented a comparative study on the U.S.and China's faculty information of Institutes of Library and Information Science.An multi-sided analysis has been made in five aspects: the number of teachers,gender,type,title and academic background information.Then the respective characteristics have been concluded as reference for further improvement of China's Library and Information Science discipline construction.
An Informetric Comparison on LIS Methodology between Chinese and Foreign Articles

Zhang Li,Tang Jianhui,Liu Yongtao,Han Songtao,Pan Youneng,Chen Lijun,Ye Ying

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-8867.2012.02.003

2012-01-01

Abstract:A sample of articles from 10 foreign and 3 Chinese core journals in library and information science during 2001-2010 was selected through systematic sampling method.The articles were analyzed and compared in terms of research methodologies using informetric method.The results showed that qualitative methods were overwhelmingly dominant in Chinese articles while quantitative methods were much more used in foreign articles.Some suggestions were proposed for the development of library and information science research in China.
Comparative Analysis on the Study of Digital Library between China and Abroad Based on Literature Clustering

Li Guiying,Feng Gengzhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-1027.2007.03.010

2007-01-01

Abstract:Choosing Chinese and foreign representative databases as the information sources, which are the full-text database of Chinese journals on the web of China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Web of Science on ISI Web of Knowledge and the famous engineering database Science Abstract (INSPEC), the paper does statistical, clustering, comparative analyses of digital library researches in the latest 30 years both domestically and abroad on five factors, which are time distribution, theme, author, periodical distribution and cited references of English literature, and conducts comparative research. Based on the comparative analyses of domestic and foreign literature, the paper explains the differences on capital, technology and human resources between China and abroad, trying to point out the problems concerning domestic researches and put forward some measures to solve them, in order to provide statistical and theoretical supports for promoting the sound development of domestic digital library.
The Differences in Education between China and the Western World and English Teaching and Learning Reform in Colleges

Wei Shao

Abstract:It is a main steam to promote the progress of educational internationalization, to foster talents with international vision, transnational culture and strong ability to participate in international competition. The western developed countries pay much attention to teaching and learning reform of foreign language and make achievements to attract the world attention. We should learn the educational differences and compare with them to improve the English teaching level in our country.

Linguistics,Education,Political Science
An Analysis of the International Academic Influence of Academic Journals in China over the Three Decades Since Reform and Opening Up

聂珍钊,石挺,杜娟

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5420.2010.01.001

2010-01-01

Abstract:Academic journals,by which academic influence of a country is indicated,provide important sources for research.The number of papers collected by the three US science citation databases(SCI,SSCI,AHCI) is an important index of a discipline's international academic influence.An analysis of academic papers indexed by the three science citation databases over the last three decades in our country reveals that great gaps exist in the number of papers indexed by each database,which embodies great imbalance in the development and international academic influence of the three subjects,of which natural science developed at a high speed,social science developed rapidly,and art and humanities developed slowly.In order to enhance the international academic influence of our country,policies should be stipulated to balance the development of different subjects.The way to classify subjects should be reformed: the philosophical social science should be divided into two subjects——social science and art humanities.Correct methods should be used in evaluating different subjects and measures should be taken to assist academic journals in entering international citation databases and thereby promote the internationalization.
Status and Prospect of Comparative Literature Research Between China and Japan

Jing Yao

2006-01-01

Abstract:As a hot subject in China,the comparative literature research between China and Japan is rapidly developing.Nevertheless,there are some important problems in orientation and methods for the subject growing in different platform and short of efficiency together and exchange.Using the methodology of Japanese literature in China,the status of comparative literature between China and Japan,and prospect of comparative literature between China and Japan,we can realize entirely the status and prospect of comparative literature research between China and Japan.
Comparative Study on University Library Websites Link Structure in China and America

杨石山,孙建军

IF: 8.1

2011-01-01

Information Sciences

Abstract:Besides indexes which were widely used by former link analysis research,this paper proposed three new indexes- portal index,return rate of homepage and link optimization index to evaluate homepage ' s link structure.Using those indexes a comparative research on link structure of top 20 universities ' library websites in China and America was made.In the end of this research,Gray Related Analysis method was used to give a link structure rank of university library websites in each country.
Factors Influencing Chinese Authors' Perceptions of Journal Quality: A Comparison Between Two Academic Fields

Zili Zhang,Ziqiong Zhang,Xiangyang Li,Minghui Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.serrev.2011.12.002

2012-01-01

Serials Review

Abstract:Numerous studies published in the academic literature address the issue of journal quality assessment. However, little has been done to compare the factors that influence the perceptions of journal quality in different disciplines. From Chinese authors' viewpoint, this study explored the factors influencing author quality perceptions of journals in computer science and technology as well as in library and information science. Our empirical findings indicate that author-perceived journal quality in these two fields is significantly positively correlated with impact factors and not statistically significantly correlated with technical delay and immediacy index. Slightly different results are also found between the two fields in terms of the effects of editor service, editorial delay and acceptance rates. (C) 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Comparison of Research on Social Media in China and Foreign Countries Based on Bibliometric Analysis

Peng Yunan,Wang Zongshui,Feng Yueyang,Yang shengqin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1616/1/012066

2020-08-01

Journal of Physics: Conference Series

Abstract:Abstract This paper aims to compare the similarities and differences of Chinese and foreign research on social media. Cluster analysis, co-word analysis and social network analysis have been used to compare the research trends, content relevance and network structure of research on social media. (1) Similarities: Social media is a hot topic for scholars both in China and foreign countries; the development of social network technology leads to many new areas; social media research tends to study privacy, commerciality and service; hotspots of social media research in China and foreign countries both include social media, platform and social network. (2) Difference: Chinese research mainly focuses on big data, Wechat and Weibo, while foreign research mainly focuses on Facebook, Twitter and other kinds of social network media; Chinese research is clustered while foreign research is extensive; Chinese research pays more attention on macroscopic perspectives, such as media convergence, big data and libraries; foreign research tends to microcosmic perspectives, such as emotional analysis, crisis information dissemination, social media marketing.
Research on Comparison Between European and American Professional Sports Leagues

SHI Wu,ZHENG Fang

2008-01-01

Abstract:The methods of literature and comparison were applied to analyze the difference between European and American professional sports leagues.The main difference has some aspects,which are model of organization, model of operation,and model of profit distribution.The authors analyse the reason of difference between European and American professional sports leagues and provides the enlightenment for the development of China's professional sports.
The Study of the Current Situation and the Strategy in the Collection of Foreign Law Journals in Chinese Academic Libraries

Yi-han ZHANG,bo SHAO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-1525.2013.05.013

2013-01-01

Abstract:Based on the data sources of Guidelan,this article makes an analysis of the collection of foreign law journals of Scopus and EBSCO in five 985universities(Fudan University,Shanghai Jiao Tong University,Nanjing University,Zhejiang University and Southeast University).Several problems can be found such as: the number of paper-based foreign journals is not enough,too many duplicates of both the paper-based foreign journals and the electronic foreign journals,the number of foreign core-journals cannot always be guaranteed,the repeated collections of foreign journals are formed by so-called the discipline construction,too many duplicates of foreign law journals in different universities.This article is aiming at making a higher level collection of the foreign law journals in China academy libraries by adopting the following policies: the libraries should give the priority to the subscription of electronic journals,increase numbers and sorts of the foreign core journals,subscribe the foreign journals by considering the discipline construction,optimize the quality of journal collection,cut down the duplicates,boost the level of guarantee,and adhere to joint acknowledge,construction and sharing of the foreign journals so as to upgrade the collection level.
Evaluation on Chinese Scholarly Journal-by Subject Field

刘霞,邱均平

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-5831.2008.01.013

2008-01-01

Abstract:According to the Chinese discipline classification country standard Discipline Classification and Code,the paper first reveals the subject structure of Chinese scholarly journal,then evaluates it from two point of view: average number of journal per researcher,and average number of articles per researcher.It compares the average articles per researcher of several subject between China and America.The result indicates,there is unreasonable phenomenon of subject structure in Chinese scholarly journals.
A Comparative Study of Teaching at Universities in China and the U.S.

LIU Shan

2013-01-01

Abstract:Graduate teaching and learning in our country still need to be improved.By comparing graduate teaching at universities in China and the U.S.,specifically its providers,receivers,philosophy,contents,methods and environment,it is suggested that American experience in teaching may be learned for the benefit of graduate training in China.
The Network of Chinese Journals in the Field of Journalism &Communication

Li Wu,Liu Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-5853.2012.03.004

2012-01-01

Abstract:Based on the journal co-citation analysis,this exploratory research aims at figuring out the network of Chinese journals in the field of journalism & communication.By statistical analysis,we find:(1)The journals are divided into two main branches:journals of journalism & communication and journals of editing & publishing.(2)Within journals of journalism & communication,except TV Research and China Radio & TV Academic Journal,there are mainly two sub-groups: research-oriented journals and industry-oriented journals.(3)Within journals of editing & publishing,except Reading and China Book Review,the others are classified into three sub-groups: journals of scientific editing & publishing,journals focusing on publishing,and journals focusing on editing.

Comparison Between Journal of Academic Libraries and College & Research Libraries

Comparative Study of Chinese-English Scientific Topic Ranking Correlations: Computer Science Perspective

Comparison and Analysis of Chinese Journal of Medical Education in Different Period

A Comparative Study of Educational Research in China and the United States

Analysis on the Application of Comparative Method in Library Science Research in China from 2002 to 2008

Comparative Analysis of the Retrieval Functions of China Journal Database and Its Influence Factors

A Comparison between A Guide to the Core Journal of China and Chinese Science Citation Database

Comparative Study of Faculty of American and China's Institute of Library and Information Science

An Informetric Comparison on LIS Methodology between Chinese and Foreign Articles

Comparative Analysis on the Study of Digital Library between China and Abroad Based on Literature Clustering

The Differences in Education between China and the Western World and English Teaching and Learning Reform in Colleges

An Analysis of the International Academic Influence of Academic Journals in China over the Three Decades Since Reform and Opening Up

Status and Prospect of Comparative Literature Research Between China and Japan

Comparative Study on University Library Websites Link Structure in China and America

Factors Influencing Chinese Authors' Perceptions of Journal Quality: A Comparison Between Two Academic Fields

Comparison of Research on Social Media in China and Foreign Countries Based on Bibliometric Analysis

Research on Comparison Between European and American Professional Sports Leagues

The Study of the Current Situation and the Strategy in the Collection of Foreign Law Journals in Chinese Academic Libraries

Evaluation on Chinese Scholarly Journal-by Subject Field

A Comparative Study of Teaching at Universities in China and the U.S.

The Network of Chinese Journals in the Field of Journalism &Communication