Abstract:In many applications such as rationing medical care and supplies, university admissions, and the assignment of public housing, the decision of who receives an allocation can be justified by various normative criteria. Such settings have motivated the following priority-respecting allocation problem: several categories, each with a quota of interchangeable items, wish to allocate the items among a set of agents. Each category has a list of eligible agents and a priority ordering over these agents; agents may be eligible in multiple categories. The goal is to select a valid allocation: one that respects quotas, eligibility, and priorities and ensures Pareto efficiency. We provide an algorithmic characterization of all valid allocations, exhibiting a bijection between sets of agents who can be allocated and maximum-weight matchings under carefully chosen rank-based weights. While prior work provides a polynomial-time algorithm to locate a valid allocation, our characterization admits a simpler algorithm that enables two wide-reaching extensions: 1. Selecting valid allocations that satisfy additional criteria: Via three examples -- inclusion/exclusion of some chosen agent; agent-side Pareto efficiency vs. welfare maximization; and fairness from the perspective of allocated vs. unallocated agents -- we show that finding priority-respecting allocations subject to some secondary constraint straddles a complexity knife-edge; in each example, one problem variant can be solved efficiently, while its variant is NP-hard. 2. Efficiency-envy tradeoffs in dynamic allocation: In settings where allocations must be made to T agents arriving sequentially via some stochastic process, we show that while insisting on zero priority violations leads to an Omega(T) loss in efficiency, one can design allocation policies ensuring that the sum of the efficiency loss and priority violations in hindsight is O(1).

Implementing Monotone Allocations: the Rochetian Approach

Detecting profitable deviations

The Good, the Bad and the Submodular: Fairly Allocating Mixed Manna Under Order-Neutral Submodular Preferences

On Revenue Monotonicity in Combinatorial Auctions

Fair and Efficient Allocations Without Obvious Manipulations

Allocating with Priorities and Quotas: Algorithms, Complexity, and Dynamics

Monotonic Mechanisms for Selling Multiple Goods

Achieving Envy-Freeness with Limited Subsidies under Dichotomous Valuations

Fair and Truthful Allocations Under Leveled Valuations

Symmetric and Asymmetric Allocating Concepts Under Multiple-Goals

Implementing Randomized Allocation Rules with Outcome-Contingent Transfers

A General Framework for Fair Allocation under Matroid Rank Valuations

A Pseudo-Market Approach to Allocation with Priorities

Epistemic EFX Allocations Exist for Monotone Valuations

Constrained Fair and Efficient Allocations

Fair and Efficient Allocations under Subadditive Valuations

On Fairness and Efficiency in Nonprofit Operations: Dynamic Resource Allocations

Multiresource Allocation: Fairness-Efficiency Tradeoffs in a Unifying Framework.

Fair Division with Allocator's Preference

Fair and Truthful Mechanisms for Dichotomous Valuations

Regularized Online Allocation Problems: Fairness and Beyond