Abstract:Public sector wage research has evolved beyond the estimation of public sector wage premiums to investigating the nature of interrelationships between public and private wage patterns. This article seeks to extend this wage leadership research to investigate intra-industry linkages and spillovers between public and private sector wage growth in Education and Health industries, using Australia as a case study. The research employs vector error correction models to encompass tests for full wage adaptability, long-run and short-run wage leadership. Results show that the public sector is the long-run leader in all models, regardless of industry and alternative jurisdictions' public sector wage setting policy. Our findings have important policy implications for public sector wage setting practices, demonstrating that wage policies which may be based on political motivations can have widespread effects on the private sector.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the leadership relationship in wage growth between the public and private sectors in the Australian state - level education and health industries. Specifically, the research aims to test full - wage adaptability, long - term wage leadership and short - term wage leadership by using the Vector Error Correction Model (VECM) to understand which sector (public or private) plays a leading role in wage setting in these industries.
### Main problems:
1. **Wage leadership relationship**: In the education and health industries, is the public sector the leader in wage growth, or is it the private sector?
2. **Policy impact**: What is the impact of the public sector's wage policies (such as wage caps) on the wage growth of the private sector?
3. **Internal industry relationships**: In industries with a large number of public and private - sector workers, is there a mutual influence on wages?
### Research background:
- **Historical research**: Early research mainly focused on estimating the public - sector wage premium, while in recent years research has shifted to the inter - relationship and leadership relationship between public and private - sector wages.
- **Australian situation**: In Australia, there are a considerable proportion of public - sector and private - sector workers in the education and health industries. For example, in the education industry, about 50% of workers are employed in the public sector; in the health industry, about 25% of workers are employed in the public sector.
- **Policy differences**: There are differences in public - sector wage policies in different states. For example, New South Wales (NSW) implemented a 2.5% wage cap from 2011 to 2022, while Victoria did not implement a similar policy until 2019.
### Methods:
- **Data sources**: Use unpublished quarterly wage price index (WPI) data provided by the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), covering education and health industry data from September 2008 to March 2023.
- **Model**: Adopt the Vector Error Correction Model (VECM) to test full - wage adaptability, long - term wage leadership and short - term wage leadership.
### Results:
- **Full - wage adaptability**: In the Victoria model, full - wage adaptability was rejected, but it was not rejected in the New South Wales model. The actual β coefficient indicates that approximately half of the wage growth is transmitted between the two sectors.
- **Long - term wage leadership**: In all four models, the public sector was identified as the long - term wage leader. This means that the private - sector wages will adjust to correct the deviation from the long - term relationship with the public - sector wage growth, while the public sector will not.
- **Short - term feedback effects**: Short - term feedback effects were observed in three out of the four models.
### Policy implications:
- **Broad impact**: The public - sector wage policies not only directly affect public - sector workers, but may also affect private - sector workers through the wage leadership relationship. In particular, in New South Wales, the wage cap not only affected public - sector workers, but also affected the wage growth of private - sector workers.
- **Macroeconomic consequences**: A long - term wage cap may lead to adverse macroeconomic impacts, such as slow wage growth and a slowdown in economic growth.
### Summary:
This research reveals the leading role of the public sector in wage setting and its impact on the private sector by analyzing the wage dynamics in the Australian state - level education and health industries. This finding is of great significance for understanding the wage leadership relationship and formulating public - sector wage policies.