Abstract:In light of recent advancements in generative AI models, it has become essential to distinguish genuine content from AI-generated one to prevent the malicious usage of fake materials as authentic ones and vice versa. Various techniques have been introduced for identifying AI-generated images, with watermarking emerging as a promising approach. In this paper, we analyze the robustness of various AI-image detectors including watermarking and classifier-based deepfake detectors. For watermarking methods that introduce subtle image perturbations (i.e., low perturbation budget methods), we reveal a fundamental trade-off between the evasion error rate (i.e., the fraction of watermarked images detected as non-watermarked ones) and the spoofing error rate (i.e., the fraction of non-watermarked images detected as watermarked ones) upon an application of diffusion purification attack. To validate our theoretical findings, we also provide empirical evidence demonstrating that diffusion purification effectively removes low perturbation budget watermarks by applying minimal changes to images. The diffusion purification attack is ineffective for high perturbation watermarking methods where notable changes are applied to images. In this case, we develop a model substitution adversarial attack that can successfully remove watermarks. Moreover, we show that watermarking methods are vulnerable to spoofing attacks where the attacker aims to have real images identified as watermarked ones, damaging the reputation of the developers. In particular, with black-box access to the watermarking method, a watermarked noise image can be generated and added to real images, causing them to be incorrectly classified as watermarked. Finally, we extend our theory to characterize a fundamental trade-off between the robustness and reliability of classifier-based deep fake detectors and demonstrate it through experiments.

Attack on Cocktail Watermarking Based on High False Positive Probability

Exposure Time Change Attack on Image Watermarking Systems

COUNTERFEITING ATTACKS ON TWO ROBUST WATERMARKING SCHEMES

A Watermarking Algorithm for Image Content Authentication in Double-Compression Environment

Counterfeiting Attack on a Lossless Authentication Watermarking Scheme.

A Pollution Attack to Public-key Watermarking Schemes.

Fooling Public-Key Watermarking Detectors with Optimal Color Noise

Invertibility attack against watermarking based on forged algorithm and a countermeasure

Adaptive Collusion Attack To A Block Oriented Watermarking Scheme

Methods for countering attacks on image watermarking schemes: Overview

A Transfer Attack to Image Watermarks

Fragile Watermarking Based on Robust Hidden Information

Synchronous Counterfeiting Attacks on Self-Embedding Watermarking Schemes

Tampering Attacks On Binary Phase Only Filter-Based Watermarking Schemes For Image Authentication

Robustness of AI-Image Detectors: Fundamental Limits and Practical Attacks

On The Security Of A Fragile Digital Image Watermarking Scheme

A Robust Watermark Algorithm Based On Wavelet

An Efficient Blind Detection Algorithm for Digital Image Watermarking

Watermark Detection Schemes with High Security

Enhanced sensitivity attack on watermarking scheme with anti-attack capability

Attacks on Robustness of Digital Watermarking and the Responding Remedies